Chippendale, Sydney · Acting for clients across NSW

What Can I Do If an Existing Employee Refuses to Sign a New Restraint Clause?

Monique Hennessy

Key Takeaways

  • Draft legislation: Existing non-competes continue under current law until any final provisions commence.
  • $190,100 threshold: The proposed ban covers employees earning at or below $190,100, with casual employees and pieceworkers covered regardless of earnings.
  • Co-worker non-solicitation: The proposal would prohibit co-worker non-solicitation terms for all employees, regardless of their earnings.
  • Employer preparation: Employers should review current restraints and identify the business interests each clause is intended to protect.

Introduction

An existing employee may refuse to sign a new post-employment restraint because of concerns about its scope, confidential information, client relationships or a possible new employer. A restraint of trade clause is not a unilateral management instruction, and refusal does not automatically justify dismissal.

Employers need to assess whether the proposed restraint is reasonable and enforceable, whether the change is voluntary, and whether a benefit or deed is needed to support it. The discussion covers lawful variation, employee objections, pressure or duress, and the risks of unfair dismissal or adverse action before employment action is taken.

Interactive Tool: Find Out What to Do When Your Employee Refuses a Restraint Clause

Employee Restraint Clause Action Checker

Unsure what to do if an employee refuses to sign a new restraint clause? Get a tailored, law-backed action plan in minutes.

What is your main concern regarding the employee’s refusal to sign the new restraint clause?

Has the employee raised specific objections to the restraint clause or related terms (e.g., commission, scope)?

❌ Dismissal for Refusal is Not Automatically Lawful

Under Section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and Section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), dismissing an employee solely for refusing to sign a new restraint clause is not a valid reason for termination. The Fair Work Commission in Clint Dupre v Excell Protective Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2313 found that refusal to sign, especially where amendments were requested, does not constitute misconduct or unsatisfactory performance. Employers risk unfair dismissal claims if they treat refusal as grounds for termination.

Section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Clint Dupre v Excell Protective Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2313

Speak to an Employment Law Lawyer

⚖️ Lawful Variation Requires Employee Agreement

You cannot unilaterally impose a new post-employment restraint on an existing employee. The court in Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley (2018) confirmed that a lawful contract variation must be supported by the employee’s voluntary agreement. Ongoing employment alone is not sufficient consideration for a new restraint. Ensure any changes are agreed to in writing and supported by a clear benefit.

Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley (2018)

Get Legal Advice on Employment Contract Variation

⚠️ Valid Consideration is Essential for Enforceability

For a new restraint clause to be enforceable, the employee must receive something of value—such as a promotion, pay rise, or bonus—linked to the new contract. As held in Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley (2018), continued employment alone is not enough. Alternatively, a deed may be used where ordinary consideration is absent, but voluntary agreement is still required.

Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley (2018)

Get Advice on Valid Consideration

⚠️ Pressure or Threats May Lead to Unfair Dismissal or Duress Claims

Applying pressure, threatening dismissal, or reducing benefits to force an employee to sign a new restraint clause can create evidence of duress and increase the risk of an unfair dismissal claim. In Clint Dupre v Excell Protective Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2313, the Fair Work Commission found that such conduct contributed to a finding of unfair dismissal.

Clint Dupre v Excell Protective Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2313

Speak to an Employment Law Lawyer Before Taking Action

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Why SME Employers Seek a New Restraint Now

Evaluating the Business Decision to Update Contracts

An SME owner may revisit its contracts when an employee’s role gives them access to valuable clients, confidential information or business relationships. Consider a digital agency whose long-serving account manager manages key client accounts and knows how those clients choose suppliers. The owner may consider a post-employment restraint because the employee’s move to a new employer could affect those relationships.

A restraint of trade clause can appear simpler and less costly than proving that a former employee misused confidential information or solicited clients. However, the business may face costs for employee consideration and legal drafting. Standard clauses can also create risks if they are used without assessing whether the restraint is reasonably necessary for the particular role.

Protecting Legitimate Business Interests

An employer may seek an enforceable restraint to protect legitimate business interests, such as:

  • confidential information;
  • trade secrets; and
  • client relationships developed through the employment relationship.

Courts have also recognised connections with customers and suppliers where the employee became the human face of the business or gained influence through their role. Mere competition by a former employee is not, by itself, a legitimate business interest.

In Woolworths Limited v Mark Konrad Olson [2004] NSWCA 372 (‘Woolworths v Olson’), the New South Wales Court of Appeal recognised that a restraint could protect valuable confidential information accessible to a senior employee. The Court observed that a reasonable restraint may be easier to enforce than a claim based on misuse of confidential information because it can provide clearer boundaries around the conduct being restricted.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Concerns Has Your Employee Raised?

Understanding Employee Objections to Restraints

An employee may object to the scope of a proposed non-solicitation clause, especially if it appears to cover clients, associated entities or business relationships outside the employee’s role. The employee may also question a new commission structure, including a higher sales target or a lack of transparency about how commission payments are calculated.

In Clint Dupre v Excell Protective Group Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 2313 (‘Dupre’), the employee raised concerns about both the proposed post-employment restraint and commission arrangements. The Fair Work Commission found that dismissing the employee for declining to sign the new contract, where his requested amendments had not been made, was not based on misconduct or unsatisfactory performance.

The decision shows why an employer should identify and consider each objection rather than treating refusal as a failure to follow a management instruction.

Reassessing the Level of Protection Sought

An employer should test whether the proposed restraint of trade clause protects a specific legitimate interest or goes further than necessary. Relevant questions include:

  • whether the clause is directed to confidential information or client relationships; and
  • whether its time period, geographic area and restricted activities are reasonable for the employee’s role.

A broad non-compete clause may be difficult to justify where a targeted non-solicitation or confidentiality clause would address the identified risk. The proposed change should be treated as a contractual variation requiring agreement, not as a unilateral management instruction. An employee’s existing duties and contract should be assessed separately from the employer’s request for a new post-employment restraint.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Can Founders Introduce a New Restraint Without Agreement?

The Requirement for Lawful Variation & Voluntariness

An employer cannot unilaterally force an existing employee to accept a new employment contract containing more onerous restraint of trade clauses. A change to the employee’s contractual obligations requires a lawful variation supported by the employee’s voluntary agreement, so employers should obtain advice from employment contract lawyers in Sydney.

In Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley [2018] EWHC 1972 (QB) (‘Tenon FM v Cawley’), an English High Court decision, the court considered more severe post-employment restraints introduced during an existing employment relationship. Although not binding in Australia, the decision illustrates that continuing employment does not, by itself, establish agreement to new restraints that operate only after employment ends.

Why Ongoing Employment May Not Be Sufficient Consideration

Ongoing employment may amount to consideration in some Australian cases, but it should not be assumed sufficient for every variation. A clearly identified benefit linked to the new restraint can reduce uncertainty.

In Commsupport Pty Ltd v Mirow [2018] QDC 134, the court accepted continued employment as consideration, although the restraint failed on reasonableness. The English decision Tenon FM v Cawley does not establish a universal Australian rule.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Benefit or Documentation Is Needed?

Providing Valid Consideration for Contract Changes

An employer seeking to introduce a new post-employment restraint during an existing employment relationship should offer a benefit in exchange for the employee’s agreement. Possible benefits include:

  • a promotion;
  • a pay rise; or
  • a bonus made conditional on signing the new contract.

The benefit should be clear and connected to the proposed contract change. An employee’s continued employment, without more, is unlikely to provide sufficient consideration for a more onerous restraint of trade clause. The employee must agree voluntarily rather than being told that the restraint is simply a new management instruction.

Using Deeds & Confidentiality Agreements

A deed may provide a formal way to record a new post-employment restraint where ordinary consideration is absent. The employer should obtain express agreement and avoid treating the deed as accepted merely because the employee continues working. A deed addresses consideration only, so the restraint must still be reasonable.

A confidentiality agreement may offer more targeted protection where the concern is confidential information rather than competition itself. It can address information such as:

  • trade secrets;
  • product information; or
  • client lists.

This can be done without preventing the employee from working for a new employer. The agreement should identify the information requiring protection; wording broad enough to restrict ordinary use of the employee’s skills and experience may create enforceability concerns.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Risks Arise From Threatening Dismissal or Reducing Benefits?

Unfair Dismissal & Adverse Action Risks

Dismissing an employee because they refuse to sign a new restraint of trade clause can expose an employer to an unfair dismissal claim and related adverse action concerns. Under section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘Fair Work Act’), a person is dismissed if their employment is terminated at the employer’s initiative. Under section 387 of the Fair Work Act, the Fair Work Commission considers, among other matters, whether there was a valid reason related to the employee’s conduct or capacity.

In Dupre, the Fair Work Commission found that dismissing an employee for declining to sign a proposed new contract, where his requested amendments had not been made, was not misconduct or unsatisfactory performance. The dismissal was found to be unfair, and compensation was ordered.

The Dangers of Duress & Unilateral Management Instructions

Pressure to sign a post-employment restraint can create evidence that the employee did not agree voluntarily. Threats about dismissal, disciplinary action or the loss of benefits may also support an argument that the employer treated a contractual variation as a unilateral management instruction.

In Dupre, an email stating that a decision would be made about the employee’s role if agreement was not reached, followed by pressure to sign without amendments, contributed to the Commission’s finding of a campaign of pressure and that the employee was dismissed at the employer’s initiative. The Commission also found that the employer had not offered the employee a genuine alternative to signing. The Commission did not need to decide a separate duress claim.

Reducing benefits or presenting continued employment as conditional on immediate acceptance may increase the risk of an unfair dismissal claim and a dispute about duress.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

How Else Can Employers Manage the Business Risk?

Exploring Practical Options & Commercial Costs

An employer may rely on existing common law duties of fidelity and confidentiality rather than seeking a broad post-employment restraint of trade clause. These duties may restrict conduct such as competing while still employed or misusing confidential information. However, they may not provide the same clear boundaries as an enforceable restraint.

Statutory protections may also be relevant. Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (‘Corporations Act’) prohibits a current or former employee of a corporation from improperly using information obtained through their position to gain an advantage, benefit another person or cause detriment to the corporation. Relying on these protections may reduce drafting and negotiation costs, although a dispute about misuse can still require evidence and legal proceedings.

Implementing Targeted Confidentiality & Non-Disclosure Agreements

A targeted confidentiality or non-disclosure agreement may address the identified risk without preventing an employee from working for a new employer. The agreement can identify information that the employee must not disclose or misuse, including:

  • trade secrets;
  • product information;
  • client lists; and
  • business methods or processes.

The restriction should not be so broad that it prevents the employee from using ordinary skills, experience or non-confidential know-how in a new role.

Monitoring Proposed Legislative Reforms

The Competition and Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Banning Unfair Non-Competes) Bill 2026 (‘Non-Competes Bill’) remains proposed reform based on an exposure draft and explanatory materials, released on 7 September 2026 with consultation closed on 2 October 2026. It is not commenced law, so the draft provisions do not presently replace the existing rules governing restraint of trade clauses.

The proposed reform would address non-compete terms for employees at or below the Fair Work Act high income threshold and would also address co-worker non-solicitation terms. The exposure draft proposes related amendments to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (‘Competition and Consumer Act’) concerning no-poach and wage-fixing agreements. SME employers should monitor whether the Bill changes, passes Parliament or commences before revising employment arrangements.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Conclusion

An employer generally cannot treat refusal to sign a new post-employment restraint of trade clause as misconduct or automatic grounds for dismissal. Agreement should be voluntary, supported by appropriate consideration or a deed, and directed to a legitimate business interest, while targeted confidentiality protections may address confidential information without a broad non-compete clause.

Before taking employment action, contact Connected Legal to discuss the existing agreement and your business objective. Our employment contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial can assess the proposed restraint, available alternatives and employment risks before you seek a signature or end employment.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. You should obtain advice specific to your circumstances before relying on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

JUMP TO...

JUMP TO...

Table of Contents

GET IN TOUCH

Talk it through with a senior lawyer.

Tell us what’s happening in your business. We’ll discuss your situation and outline next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Client reviews

What our clients say

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Insights

Plain-English notes & legal insights for business owners

Contact

Request a consultation

An obligation-free 15-minute conversation about your matter. We’ll explain where you stand and what your next steps could be.

Phone

Office

Level 5, The Brewery, 5 Central Park Avenue, Chippendale.
Working with clients across Greater Sydney and NSW.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

FIXED-FEE REVIEW
Privacy Policy Truth Check

Before 10 December 2026

Is your privacy policy telling the truth?

New privacy policy rules for automated decision-making start on 10 December 2026. Our fixed-fee Truth Check reviews your policy against how your business actually operates, for $1,290 + GST.

Engagements confirmed by 10 December 2026 include the automated decision-making check.