Introduction
A restraint of trade clause in an employment contract does not automatically end or continue when an Australian employer dismisses an employee or makes their role redundant. Whether it can be enforced depends on how the employment ended, what the contract says, and whether the clause protects a legitimate business interest without going further than reasonably necessary.
The position can differ where the employee resigns, or where the employee accepts the employer’s repudiatory breach (serious breach going to the root of the contract). Statutory dismissal rights under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘Fair Work Act‘) are a separate issue from whether a contractual restraint is enforceable. This article explains how the termination method, the contract wording, survival clauses and legitimate business interests can affect a restraint of trade clause and post-employment obligations for SME employers.
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Restraint of Trade Clause Is Enforceable
Restraint of Trade Enforceability Checker
Quickly assess if your restraint of trade clause is likely to be enforceable after dismissal or redundancy.
1 of 3 | How was the employment relationship ended?
2 of 3 | Does the employment contract contain a restraint of trade clause with clear survival wording?
3 of 3 | Does the restraint protect a legitimate business interest and is it reasonable in scope?
✅ Likely Enforceable Restraint
Speak to a Lawyer about Enforcing Your Restraint❌ Restraint Unlikely to be Enforceable After Employer Breach
Get Legal Advice on Restraint Disputes⚠️ Restraint May Not Be Enforceable
Speak to a Lawyer about Drafting or Challenging a Restraint⚖️ Contract Unclear – Legal Review Recommended
Get Employment Law Advice from a LawyerResignation vs Employer-Initiated Termination
Identifying an Employer-Initiated Termination
Under section 386(1) of the Fair Work Act, a person is dismissed if:
- their employment was terminated on the employer’s initiative (section 386(1)(a)); or
- they resigned but were forced to do so because of the employer’s conduct or a course of conduct (Section 386(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act).
For the first limb, the question in broad terms is whether the employer’s action directly and consequentially caused the employment to end, so that the employee would not otherwise have left. A dismissal and a redundancy will usually fall within it. A resignation may be treated as a dismissal under the second limb if the employee had no real choice but to resign.
These are statutory concepts used mainly for unfair dismissal and similar claims. They do not decide whether a restraint clause is enforceable, which is a question of contract law and equity.
How Resignation Affects Restraint Enforceability
A genuinely voluntary resignation will usually leave the employer in a stronger position to rely on a restraint, because the employer has not ended the relationship or acted inconsistently with the contract.
However, resignation does not make a restraint enforceable automatically. The clause must still protect a legitimate business interest and go no further than reasonably necessary, having regard to its duration, geographic scope and restricted activities. An employee who resigns in response to the employer’s serious breach may also argue that they accepted a repudiation, which is discussed below.
Reviewing Restraints Before Dismissal or Redundancy
Employment Contract and Restraint Clauses
Read the contract before deciding how to end the employment. Use this checklist:
- Wording: Does the clause apply on termination “for any reason”, or only in certain circumstances such as resignation?
- Type of restraint: Is it a non-compete, a non-solicitation of clients, a non-solicitation of staff, a confidentiality obligation, or a combination?
- Duration: How long does each restriction last, and is that period justified for this role?
- Geographic scope: Is the area tied to where the business actually operates?
- Restricted activities: Are they limited to what the employee actually did or knew?
- Role and seniority: Does the employee have real influence over clients or staff?
- Confidential information: What information did the employee access that could be misused?
- Cascading wording: If the clause offers alternative periods or areas, is each alternative clear and reasonable?
- Governing law: Is the contract governed by NSW law, which affects how courts treat over-broad clauses (see below)?
- Employer compliance: Has the business paid all entitlements, including bonuses, and followed the contract?
A restraint is more likely to be supported where it protects customer connections, confidential information or staff stability (recognised protectable interests). A broad non-compete may be hard to enforce if the business cannot explain why its length, reach and scope are needed. Courts have taken differing approaches to cascading clauses, so they should be reviewed carefully.
Genuine Redundancy Process
Under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a dismissal is a genuine redundancy only if all three conditions are met:
- Operational changes mean the employer no longer needs anyone to perform the employee’s job.
- The employer has met any obligation to consult about the redundancy under an applicable modern award or enterprise agreement. Check the consultation clause for the required timing and steps.
- Redeploying the employee within the employer’s business or an associated entity’s business would have been unreasonable in all the circumstances. Fair Work Commission.
A genuine redundancy rules out an unfair dismissal remedy. Whether the employer can enforce a post-employment restraint is a separate question.
Assessing Commercial Costs and Practical Options
Before acting, consider whether redeployment to another role is reasonably available. Section 120 also allows the Fair Work Commission, on the employer’s application, to reduce redundancy pay if the employer finds other acceptable employment for the employee.
Weigh the likely value of enforcing the restraint against the cost of a dispute, court proceedings or an injunction application. A digital agency may focus on client connections and confidential information. A general SME may find that narrower non-solicitation and confidentiality obligations are more proportionate and easier to enforce than a broad non-compete.
Employer Breach and the Restraint
What Is Repudiation in Plain English?
Repudiation occurs when a party’s conduct, viewed objectively, shows an intention not to be bound by the contract (or to perform it only in a way inconsistent with its terms). The employer’s private intention is not decisive; the question is how the conduct would appear to a reasonable person in the employee’s position. Not every breach is repudiation, as the breach must be serious enough to go to the root of the contract.
Conduct that may amount to repudiation, depending on its seriousness and context, includes:
- reducing wages without consent;
- changing duties or the work location outside what the contract allows;
- altering a bonus arrangement without contractual authority; or
- applying a bonus scheme in a way that departs from its agreed terms, such as excluding profits the scheme includes.
The Impact of Accepted Repudiation on Restraints
Repudiation does not end the contract by itself. The employee may:
- accept the repudiation and treat the contract as ended; or
- affirm the contract and keep working under it.
In Crowe Horwath (Aust) Pty Ltd v Loone (2017) 54 VR 517 (‘Crowe Horwath‘), the Victorian Court of Appeal upheld the finding that the employer had repudiated the contract in the way it dealt with the agreed bonus arrangements. The employee accepted the repudiation, and the court declined to enforce the restraint.
This reflects the long-standing principle that a party who has breached the contract in a fundamental way cannot readily enforce a restraint against the other party. As a Victorian decision, it is persuasive rather than binding in other states.
Distinguishing Lawful Termination from Contractual Breach
A lawful dismissal or redundancy, carried out in accordance with the contract and with proper notice, can end the employment without amounting to repudiation. A lawful termination does not, by itself, cancel the restraint or guarantee it will be enforced.
By contrast, an employer who terminates in breach of the contract, for example by ending employment without the required notice or without a contractual right to pay in lieu, risks arguments that the restraint no longer binds. The outcome depends on:
- the contract wording;
- the employer’s conduct before and during the exit; and
- whether the employer breached an obligation to the employee.
Any statutory dismissal claim must be assessed separately from the restraint question.
Notice, Payment in Lieu and Survival Clauses
Working the Notice Period vs Payment in Lieu
Section 117 of the Fair Work Act sets minimum notice periods, which increase with length of service (and with age for employees over 45 with at least two years’ service). An employer may end employment by giving the required notice, or by paying the employee the amount they would have received had they worked the notice period, calculated at the full rate of pay. The contract or an award may require longer notice.
The two options differ in effect:
- If the employee works their notice, the employment continues until the stated end date, and the restraint period generally starts from that date.
- Payment in lieu can bring employment to an immediate end, so the restraint may start earlier.
Check that the contract actually permits payment in lieu. If it does not, ending employment immediately may itself be a breach, which could support an argument against enforcing the restraint.
The Role of Survival Wording in Contracts
Survival wording identifies which obligations continue after employment ends. Contracts commonly state that the following survive termination:
- confidentiality obligations;
- non-compete clauses;
- non-solicitation obligations; and
- other restraints.
Employers should confirm that the clause applies to the particular type of termination being considered. For example, some clauses are expressed to apply on resignation only, or exclude redundancy. Survival wording does not cure an unreasonable restraint, so it should be read alongside the employee’s role, the legitimate interests claimed and the limits of the clause.
Can an Exit Deed Change a Restraint?
Reaffirming or Modifying Restraints by Agreement
An exit deed (or separation agreement) records what the employer and departing employee agree about post-employment obligations. Depending on negotiations, it may:
- reaffirm the existing restraint;
- narrow its duration or activities; or
- release the employee from some restrictions.
The deed should identify the legitimate business interests being protected, such as customer connections, confidential information or staff relationships. The usual reasonableness requirements still apply, and a court can decline to enforce an unreasonable restraint even if the employee signed it. An exit deed also cannot remove minimum entitlements under the Fair Work Act.
Practical Examples for Digital Agencies and General SMEs
A digital agency may use an exit deed to record that a departing account manager will not solicit identified clients or use client lists and contact details obtained during employment. A limited non-solicitation obligation can protect client connections without stopping the employee from working elsewhere.
A general SME may focus on staff relationships rather than a broad non-compete, for example by addressing whether the departing manager may encourage named employees to leave. Note that the proposed federal reforms discussed below may affect staff non-solicitation clauses, so this approach should be reviewed against the latest position.
When to Get Legal Advice
Pre-Exit Planning and Risk Assessment
SME employers should obtain advice before communicating a redundancy or dismissal where the employee is subject to a restraint, has significant customer connections or holds confidential information. Preferably, the contract should be reviewed by employment contract lawyers in Sydney. A pre-exit checklist:
- Confirm the restraint wording and whether it applies to the intended termination method.
- Confirm the notice entitlement and whether the contract permits payment in lieu.
- Check that all entitlements (wages, leave, bonuses) are correct and up to date.
- Identify the legitimate interests the business needs to protect, and whether a narrower restraint would be enough.
- Confirm redundancy genuineness, including consultation and redeployment, and whether redundancy pay applies.
- Consider whether an exit deed is appropriate, and what it should say.
- Plan the exit communication so it is consistent with the contract.
Managing Complex Restraint Enforceability
Early advice is especially useful where the clause includes a non-compete, non-solicitation or confidentiality restriction, because each is assessed differently. A digital agency may need to protect client connections and confidential information, while a general SME may have a stronger basis for a narrower restriction on identified customers or staff.
In New South Wales, section 4 of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) (‘Restraints of Trade Act‘) provides that a restraint is valid to the extent that it is not against public policy, whether or not it is in severable terms.
Where NSW law governs the contract, this lets courts read down an over-broad restraint rather than strike it out entirely. It does not guarantee enforcement, and a clause may still fail if it goes too far.
Conclusion
A dismissal or redundancy does not, by itself, cancel or preserve a restraint of trade clause. The result depends on the termination method, the contract, the employer’s own conduct and whether the clause reasonably protects a legitimate interest. An employer’s contractual breach, including a repudiation the employee accepts, may affect post-employment restrictions, while any statutory dismissal claim remains a separate issue.
Before communicating an exit, contact our employment contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial to discuss the specific agreement, the proposed termination and your business objective. Our commercial lawyers for business owners in Sydney can help assess the restraint, contractual risks and practical options before the decision is communicated.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.