Introduction
Hiring someone from a competitor is not automatically unlawful, but a non-compete clause in the candidate’s employment contract may restrict the role you have in mind. Before making an offer, an employer should assess the actual restraint, including any post-employment restraint, non-solicitation clause, time period, geographical scope and governing law.
The decision also involves confidential information, client relationships and the risk of being accused of inducing a breach of the candidate’s contract. This article explains the issues Australian SME employers should review before confirming employment, a start date or client account allocation. It also explains the proposed reforms to non-compete clauses, which are not yet law at the time of writing.
Interactive Tool: Check Your Risk of Hiring Someone With a Non-Compete Clause
Non-Compete Clause Risk Checker
Quickly assess if hiring a candidate with a non-compete clause could expose your business to legal risk.
Does the candidate’s employment contract include a non-compete or non-solicitation clause?
Is the candidate’s proposed role likely to involve working with former clients, confidential information, or in the same geographic area as their previous employer?
Is the candidate’s income above the Fair Work Act high-income threshold ($190,100 as proposed for 2027)?
✅ Low Legal Risk: No Non-Compete or Solicitation Clauses
Based on your answers, there are no post-employment restraints in the candidate’s contract. You may proceed with the hire, but always review for confidential information and ensure compliance with Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
- Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
⚠️ Caution: Non-Compete or Non-Solicitation Clause Detected
The candidate’s contract includes a restraint. The enforceability depends on the scope, duration, and whether the new role overlaps with protected interests. In NSW, the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) allows the court to read down unreasonable clauses. Seek legal advice before proceeding.
- Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
❌ High Risk: Overlap with Former Clients or Confidential Information
Hiring a candidate into a role that overlaps with former clients, confidential information, or the same market significantly increases the risk of an injunction or litigation. Defending such a claim can cost $50,000–$700,000. Obtain urgent legal advice before confirming employment.
- Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
- Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
⚖️ Proposed Reform: Non-Compete Ban May Apply
If the candidate earns below the Fair Work Act high-income threshold, proposed reforms may ban non-compete clauses from 2027. However, these changes are not yet law. Seek legal advice to clarify your position under current and upcoming legislation.
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (proposed threshold)
- Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
⚠️ Unknown Risk: Insufficient Information
You have not confirmed the presence or absence of restraint clauses or the candidate’s income. It is essential to review the contract and clarify the proposed role before proceeding. Legal review is strongly recommended.
- Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
- Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
What Should You Ask About Before Making an Offer?
Identify Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Clauses
A non-compete clause may restrict a worker from joining a competitor or starting a competing business, usually for a stated period and within a stated area. A non-solicitation clause is narrower: it may restrict the worker from approaching former clients or inviting former co-workers to move to a new business.
Ask the candidate for a copy of their employment contract and any later restraint documents, then review:
- the actual restraint clause and any related confidentiality clause;
- the candidate’s proposed role and duties; and
- the business interests the previous employer may be trying to protect.
Restraints are assessed against a legal test. Under the common law, a restraint of trade is generally unenforceable unless it goes no further than reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate interest of the former employer, such as confidential information or client relationships. An employer cannot enforce a restraint simply to stop competition. Whether a particular clause meets that test depends on its wording and the circumstances when it was signed.
Understand the Proposed Reforms
The Government announced in the 2025–26 Budget that it would ban non-compete clauses for workers earning below the high-income threshold under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘Fair Work Act‘). On 7 September 2026, Treasury released an exposure draft of the Competition and Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Banning Unfair Non-Competes) Bill 2026 (‘draft Bill‘). Consultation closed on 2 October 2026.
As described in commentary on the draft Bill, the proposals include:
- a ban on non-compete terms for employees whose annualised full-time equivalent earnings are at or below the high-income threshold ($190,100 for the 2026–27 financial year, indexed annually);
- a ban on co-worker non-solicitation clauses for all employees, regardless of income;
- conditions for post-employment restraints that remain available for higher-income employees, including that they protect a legitimate interest and are reasonable; and
- new cartel prohibitions on no-poach and wage-fixing agreements between businesses under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).
These are proposals, not law. The draft Bill has not passed Parliament, its final content may change, and it is targeted to commence in 2027. Until it is enacted and in force, the existing common law and statute apply. Check the status of the legislation, and whether it will apply to restraints in contracts signed before commencement, before relying on it.
Does the Restraint Cover the Role?
Assess the Scope and Governing Law
Assess the restraint against the role the candidate would perform, not just the employer’s industry. Review the activities covered, the geographic area, the time period and the business interest said to justify the clause. A restraint may restrict:
- employment with a competitor;
- work with defined clients; or
- specific dealings after employment ends.
The governing law can affect enforceability. Where New South Wales law applies, the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) (‘Restraints of Trade Act‘) allows the Supreme Court of New South Wales to read down a restraint that would otherwise be against public policy because it is wider than reasonably necessary. The court may enforce it only to the extent that is reasonable. Outside NSW, courts have generally been more limited, and may only strike out unreasonable parts of a clause if what remains still makes sense (the “blue pencil” approach).
A digital agency should check whether the proposed role involves the former employer’s clients, geographic market or confidential relationships before confirming an offer.
Treat Candidate Assurances and Indemnities Carefully
A candidate’s assurance that they will comply with a restraint, or that the restraint is “not enforceable”, does not establish that the restraint is invalid. An offer to indemnify the hiring business against loss or legal costs has the same limitation: it may allocate commercial risk, but it does not decide enforceability.
Review the contract, the restraint clause and the proposed duties independently. Consider:
- the likelihood of a dispute;
- the effect on client relationships;
- the proposed start date; and
- whether the role could involve conduct the restraint prohibits.
What Can the Candidate Share?
Protect Trade Secrets and Confidential Information
A candidate may use their general skills, experience and know-how in a new role. They must not use or disclose trade secrets or confidential information belonging to their previous employer, such as product formulas, client lists, pricing or business methods.
Several sources of obligation can apply:
- Contractual confidentiality clauses may continue after employment ends.
- Equitable duties of confidence can protect confidential information even without a written clause.
- Section 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (‘Corporations Act‘) prohibits a person who obtains information as a director, other officer or employee of a corporation from improperly using it to gain an advantage for themselves or someone else, or to cause detriment to the corporation, even after they leave.
- Section 182 of the Corporations Act separately restricts the improper use of a person’s position for those purposes. It generally applies to current officers and employees of a corporation.
Whether information is “confidential” is a question of fact. General industry knowledge and skills are usually not protected in the same way as specific trade secrets or client data.
Avoid Receiving a Competitor’s Data
Make clear in writing that the candidate must not bring confidential material from their former employer into the new business. Limit any requests for documents to material the candidate is entitled to share, such as their own work samples that contain no confidential content.
Consider a digital agency hiring an account manager from another agency. The candidate may discuss their experience managing campaigns, but should not provide the former agency’s client database, pricing information or campaign files. The same applies when a general SME hires a sales employee: do not request customer lists, internal pricing records or other proprietary information.
Can You Reduce the Risk?
Plan Onboarding and Client Accounts
An employer may reduce the practical risk of a restraint by structuring the role around it. Before confirming a start date or allocating client accounts, review whether the new role involves restricted activities, former clients or particular geographic areas.
A digital agency might place a new account manager on different client accounts at the outset, or agree a later start date while the restraint is reviewed. A general SME could limit access to particular client relationships until the contract has been assessed. These steps do not show that the clause is invalid and do not guarantee protection from a dispute.
Avoid Inducing a Breach
A hiring business can be exposed to a claim if it knowingly encourages or procures a breach of the candidate’s contract. This is generally known as the tort of inducing breach of contract. Hiring someone who has a restraint is not, by itself, inducement, but encouraging the candidate to ignore the restraint, or to conceal the new role from their former employer, increases the risk.
Keep discussions focused on the proposed duties, client accounts and timing. Do not suggest the candidate solicit former clients or colleagues in a way the restraint prohibits. The former employer may also name the new employer as a respondent when seeking relief. Our employment contract lawyers in Sydney can review the agreement and proposed arrangements before you proceed.
What If the Former Employer Objects?
Understand Injunctions and Litigation Risk
A former employer may apply for an interlocutory injunction, a temporary court order that can stop the candidate starting or continuing the role while the dispute is decided. The court generally asks whether there is a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favours granting the order (Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57).
Disputes can be expensive and disruptive, even before a final hearing. Costs depend on the complexity of the matter, the urgency, and whether it proceeds to trial, so any estimate should come from your lawyer after they review the documents. A court may also grant narrower relief than the former employer asked for, such as restraining only part of the activities, or may accept undertakings.
Weigh the Commercial Costs
Compare the value of the hire with the cost, delay and uncertainty of a dispute, and consider getting advice from business and commercial lawyers on employment-related commercial disputes. Options may include:
- seeking the former employer’s agreement or waiver;
- negotiating a settlement;
- changing the proposed role, accounts or start date; or
- deciding not to proceed.
Be careful with promises about legal costs. Agreeing to fund the candidate’s defence does not make a restraint invalid, and neither the employer nor the candidate can guarantee protection from an injunction, legal costs or disruption to the employment.
Pre-Offer Checklist
Complete these steps before making a formal offer, confirming a start date or allocating client accounts:
- Obtain the candidate’s contract: Ask for the employment contract, any restraint deed and any confidentiality terms.
- Identify the restraints: List each non-compete, non-solicitation and confidentiality clause, including its duration, geographic area and the activities covered.
- Check the governing law: Confirm which State or Territory law governs the contract, and whether the Restraints of Trade Act applies.
- Compare the restraint with the role: Map the proposed duties, clients and territory against the restricted activities.
- Identify the legitimate interest: Consider whether the former employer has confidential information or client relationships it is likely to say it needs to protect.
- Check for reform: Confirm whether the proposed non-compete ban has been enacted and whether it affects this candidate’s contract and pay level.
- Give written instructions: Tell the candidate not to bring or use confidential documents, client data or pricing from their former employer.
- Plan the role and timing: Consider different accounts, duties or a later start date while the restraint is reviewed.
- Avoid inducement: Do not encourage the candidate to breach the restraint, solicit former clients or colleagues, or conceal the move.
- Set a response plan: Decide in advance how you will respond if the former employer sends a letter of demand or seeks an injunction.
- Get advice: Have a lawyer review the contract and the proposed arrangements.
When Should You Get Legal Advice?
Seek a Review Before Confirming a Start Date
Obtain advice from employment contract lawyers in Sydney before making a formal offer, confirming a start date or allocating client accounts, where the candidate has a non-compete clause or other post-employment restraint.
A review should consider:
- the employment contract and the actual restraint clause;
- the candidate’s proposed duties;
- your business objective;
- the governing law; and
- any connection with former clients or confidential information.
Advice can also help you assess the risk of an inducement claim and prepare for a possible response from the former employer.
Conclusion
Hiring from a competitor is not automatically unlawful, but an employer should examine the candidate’s agreement, the restraint, the proposed role, the governing law, confidential information and client relationships before making an offer. A candidate’s assurance or indemnity does not decide enforceability, and changing the role or timing cannot guarantee protection from a dispute or legal costs.
Proposed reforms may change the position for many employees from 2027, but they are not yet law. To discuss a candidate’s agreement and your business objective before you proceed, contact the employment contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.