Introduction
A business engaging an independent contractor or freelancer in Australia can include a restraint of trade clause in the services agreement. A restraint may help protect client relationships, goodwill, confidential information and project-specific access, but it is not automatically enforceable, and it cannot be drafted simply to stop a contractor from competing.
Key questions include whether a freelancer non-compete clause or a contractor non-solicitation clause is suitable, why an employment agreement should not simply be copied into a services agreement, and how worker classification and unfair contract term rules may affect the arrangement.
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Contractor Restraint Clause Is Enforceable
Contractor Restraint of Trade Clause Checker
Quickly check if your contractor or freelancer restraint clause is likely to be enforceable under Australian law.
Is the restraint clause designed to protect a legitimate business interest (such as client relationships, goodwill, confidential information, or trade secrets)?
Does the clause specify reasonable limits for duration, geographic area, and restricted activities?
Does the clause attempt to restrict the contractor’s pre-existing clients or unrelated projects?
✅ Likely Enforceable Restraint
Speak to a Commercial Lawyer⚠️ Risk of Unenforceable Clause
Get Business Contract Legal Advice❌ Unenforceable Restraint Likely
Speak to a Commercial Lawyer NowClient and Project Information Risks
Protecting Client Relationships and Goodwill
A contractor who works directly with clients may develop relationships that support your business’s goodwill (its reputation and client base). The risk arises if the contractor later approaches those clients, takes their business or interferes with your ongoing client relationships.
Consider a digital agency engaging a freelance account specialist who manages client communications and learns how projects are priced and delivered. A contractor non-solicitation clause may help stop the specialist from approaching those clients after the engagement, provided the clause protects a legitimate business interest and does not go further than reasonably necessary.
Safeguarding Confidential Assets and Trade Secrets
Freelancers may receive confidential information or project-specific access that could harm your business if misused. This may include client lists, trade secrets and information about your systems, projects or commercial relationships.
An SME engaging an IT consultant may provide access to internal systems, technical documentation and confidential project data. A confidentiality clause can define the information that must stay confidential and limit how the consultant may use it after the services end. A restraint clause can then address conduct that goes beyond misuse of information, such as soliciting clients. Even without a written clause, a contractor may owe an equitable duty of confidence (an obligation arising from the circumstances in which information was shared), but express wording gives the business much clearer protection.
Restricting Conduct vs All Other Work
Available Contractual Options for Your Business
A restraint of trade clause can target specific conduct without preventing a freelancer from accepting all other work. The appropriate option depends on the legitimate interest the business is protecting:
- Freelancer non-compete clause: may restrict involvement in a competing business, or the establishment of one, within defined limits.
- Contractor non-solicitation clause: may prevent the contractor from approaching or enticing specified clients.
- Non-dealing clause: goes further than non-solicitation by restricting the contractor from doing business with specified clients even where the client makes the first approach.
- Non-poach clause: may restrict soliciting or encouraging your employees to leave.
- Confidentiality (non-disclosure) clause: may restrict the use or disclosure of confidential information, trade secrets and client lists.
The distinction between soliciting and accepting an approach matters in practice, because a non-solicitation clause alone does not stop a contractor from accepting work from a client who approaches them. A restraint should reflect the contractor’s role, access and dealings rather than impose a blanket ban on work.
Reasonableness and Legitimate Interests
Restraints of trade are prima facie void (presumed unenforceable as contrary to public policy) unless they are justified. The business seeking to enforce a restraint must generally show that it protects a legitimate business interest and that it goes no further than is reasonably necessary to protect that interest, assessed as at the time the contract was made.
Protecting client relationships, goodwill, confidential information or trade secrets may support a restraint. By contrast, preventing a contractor from competing merely because competition is unwanted does not.
A court may consider factors such as:
- the restraint’s duration;
- its geographic area;
- the restricted activities;
- the nature of the business; and
- the contractor’s access to clients or confidential information.
Courts have often applied less strict scrutiny to commercial restraints than to employment restraints, but a contractor’s restraint is still assessed on its facts. A clause that goes further than reasonably necessary may be unenforceable, leaving the business without the protection it expected.
In New South Wales, section 4 of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) provides that a restraint is valid to the extent that it is not against public policy, whether or not it is in severable terms. Where NSW law governs the agreement, a court may therefore read down an over-broad restraint rather than strike it out entirely. This does not guarantee enforcement, and a clause may still fail if it goes too far.
Pre-Existing Clients and Unrelated Projects
Case Study on Managing Contractor Client Relationships
A contractor’s own existing clients should be distinguished from client relationships developed and controlled by the business. In Isaac v Dargan Financial Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 163 (‘Isaac v Dargan‘), a mortgage broker was engaged as an independent contractor and, after the engagement ended, moved to a competitor and acted for some of the principal’s clients. The Court of Appeal did not disturb the finding that the non-solicitation restraint was reasonable and had been breached, and the client list retained its confidential character despite some client details being visible online.
The Court did not find a breach of the non-interference clause because the evidence did not establish interference with existing loan relationships. It also set aside the permanent confidentiality injunction because the client list had entered the public domain when tendered in open court without confidentiality protection. The case highlights the need to match the clause to the conduct being restricted and preserve confidentiality during any dispute.
Practical Trade-Offs and Commercial Costs
An overly broad restraint can restrict a freelancer from continuing their existing business or accepting unrelated projects. It may also make the services agreement less attractive where the clause seeks to prevent competition rather than protect a defined legitimate interest.
The commercial costs may include:
- freelancers refusing to sign the services agreement;
- disputes about which clients are covered;
- court proceedings challenging the restraint; and
- the restraint being struck out, read down or treated as unenforceable.
The clause should identify the client relationships, confidential information or conduct that create the relevant risk. Unrelated projects should not be restricted merely because the contractor provides similar services elsewhere.
Contractors Operating Through a Company
Corporate Contractors vs Individual Freelancers
A restraint clause may not protect a business if it binds only the corporate contractor while the work is performed by an individual who has not agreed to it. For this reason, the agreement should identify the people who actually perform the services, such as the company’s director, and the business should consider having that individual sign the restraint personally (for example, in a separate deed).
Corporate structure also affects contractor protections. The Independent Contractors Act 2006 (Cth) (‘Independent Contractors Act‘) allows a court to review a services contract that is unfair or harsh, but its unfair contracts provisions do not apply to a body corporate contractor unless the work is wholly or mainly performed by a director or a member of a director’s family. Separately, Part 3A-5 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘Fair Work Act‘) provides a Fair Work Commission process for unfair contract terms, discussed below. Whether and how that process applies to company contractors should be checked with a lawyer.
Competition Law and Commercial Agreement Considerations
Restraints in commercial agreements are assessed differently from restraints in employment agreements, so businesses should obtain advice from business and commercial lawyers advising on commercial agreements.
The public interest in competition remains relevant. A restraint that restricts competition beyond what is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest may be unenforceable, and some restraints between competing businesses may also raise issues under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The agreement should identify the protected interest and explain why the restraint’s activities, duration and geographic scope are connected to it.
The federal Government has also announced a proposed ban on non-compete clauses for workers earning below the high income threshold, and a draft Bill was released in September 2026.
Contractor Rules and Pre-Signing Checks
Worker Classification as a Prerequisite
A restraint of trade clause should be considered only after checking that the worker is genuinely an independent contractor. For constitutionally covered businesses, such as trading companies, section 15AA generally requires assessment of both the contract and how the relationship operates in practice. Different rules can apply to sole traders, partnerships and valid opt-out arrangements.
Factors commonly considered include:
- the level of control over the work;
- financial responsibility and risk;
- who supplies tools and equipment; and
- the ability to delegate or subcontract.
An Australian Business Number or invoices do not, by themselves, establish contractor status. Misclassification carries real consequences: section 357 of the Fair Work Act prohibits an employer from representing that an employment relationship is an independent contracting arrangement, subject to a defence where the employer proves it reasonably believed, when making the representation, that the worker was engaged as an independent contractor. If the worker is in fact an employee, an employment-style restraint analysis and employee entitlements will apply.
Understanding Unfair Contract Terms Regimes
For services contracts entered into on or after 26 August 2024, an independent contractor who earns below the contractor high income threshold may apply to the Fair Work Commission under section 536ND of the Fair Work Act for a remedy. Under sections 536NA and 536NC of the Fair Work Act, the Commission may set aside or vary a term if it is satisfied the term is an unfair contract term. The term must relate to a “workplace relations matter” (defined in section 536JQ of the Fair Work Act), so a restraint clause will only be reviewable if it falls within that definition.
Contractors earning above the threshold may instead apply to a court under section 12 of the Independent Contractors Act. The contractor high income threshold for 2026–27 has been reported as $190,100, but employers should confirm the current figure with the Fair Work Commission before relying on it.
Key Discussions Before the Agreement Is Signed
The parties should discuss what the restraint clause is intended to protect before the services agreement is signed, with contract lawyers in Sydney available to advise on the agreement. A freelancer non-compete clause may not be suitable where a contractor non-solicitation clause or confidentiality protection would address the specific risk more directly.
Use this checklist before signing:
- Identify the clients, confidential information or project access that require protection.
- Specify the conduct the contractor must not engage in (for example, soliciting or dealing with named clients).
- List the contractor’s pre-existing clients and unrelated projects that the restraint will not cover.
- Explain how the contractor’s business will continue during and after the engagement.
- Confirm who performs the services and whether that individual will be bound personally.
- Check the contractor is genuinely independent under the legal test that applies to your business and the engagement.
- Choose a duration and area that match the protected interest, and confirm the governing law.
- Check whether the unfair contract terms regimes could apply to the contractor.
The contractor should understand these commercial boundaries, while the business should draft the restraint clause to reflect the actual relationship and legitimate business interest.
Conclusion
A restraint of trade clause can help protect client relationships, confidential information and goodwill, but restraints of trade are not automatically enforceable. A freelancer non-compete clause or contractor non-solicitation clause should reflect the contractor’s business, the legitimate interest involved, the actual relationship and applicable contractor protections.
Before including a restraint clause, contact the contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial to discuss your services agreement and business objective. Our commercial lawyers for business owners in Sydney can help assess the proposed restraint, distinguish it from an employment agreement, and develop contractual protections that reflect your commercial arrangements.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.