Introduction
A digital agency owner updating a staff handbook may consider adding a six-month non-compete clause, while another SME employer may ask whether a workplace policy is the right place for an employment restraint. The decision matters because following a policy during employment is not the same as agreeing to a contractual post-employment restraint.
This article explains how express incorporation, policy disclaimers, variation clauses and clear agreement to a specific restraint clause affect whether an employer can enforce post-employment restraints. It also considers practical options, commercial costs and the distinction between a restraint of trade and ordinary workplace directions.
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Non-Compete Clause Is Enforceable
Post-Employment Restraint Enforceability Checker
Find out if your staff handbook or workplace policy can legally create a binding post-employment restraint for your business.
Is the restraint clause expressly incorporated into the employee’s signed employment contract?
Did the employee sign a separate agreement or clear acknowledgement to the specific restraint clause?
Does your handbook or policy include a disclaimer stating it is not part of the employment contract?
✅ High Likelihood of Enforceability
If your restraint clause is expressly incorporated into the signed employment contract and the employee has clearly agreed to the specific terms, courts are more likely to enforce the restraint—provided it is reasonable in scope, duration, and purpose.
For SME employers, clear contractual intent and express agreement are critical. See Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50 and Goldman Sachs JBWere Services Pty Limited v Nikolich [2007] FCAFC 120; 163 FCR 62.
Always ensure the restraint is tailored to protect a legitimate business interest and is not broader than necessary.
Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act (NSW) presumes validity unless contrary to public policy.
Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50
Goldman Sachs JBWere Services Pty Limited v Nikolich [2007] FCAFC 120; 163 FCR 62
Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act (NSW)
⚠️ Uncertain or Disputed Enforceability
If the restraint is only in a handbook or policy, or the employee has not clearly agreed to the specific clause, enforceability is uncertain and may be challenged.
Courts will look for clear contractual intent and specific agreement. A general policy acknowledgement is not enough to create a binding post-employment restraint (Elisha; Nikolich).
Ambiguous or poorly drafted documentation increases the risk of expensive disputes and litigation.
Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50
Goldman Sachs JBWere Services Pty Limited v Nikolich [2007] FCAFC 120; 163 FCR 62
❌ Restraint Unlikely to Be Enforceable
A post-employment restraint that is not expressly incorporated into the contract, not specifically agreed to, or is only acknowledged as a policy, is unlikely to be enforceable in Australia.
Policy disclaimers stating the handbook is not part of the contract further weaken enforceability.
Employers should use a separate agreement or clear contract clause for any post-employment restraint. See Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSC 614; [2016] VSCA 334.
Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSC 614; [2016] VSCA 334
⚖️ Policy Update or Disclaimer Detected
If your handbook or policy includes a clear disclaimer stating it is not part of the employment contract, or you are relying on a policy update to add a restraint, the restraint is unlikely to be enforceable without a new, specific agreement.
Proposed legislative changes may further restrict non-compete clauses for some workers from 2027, but these are not yet law.
Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act (NSW)
Is the Handbook Part of the Employment Contract?
Express Incorporation & Contractual Intent
A handbook can form part of an employment contract where the contract uses clear language showing that the parties intended to be bound by its terms. The wording, context and effect of the documents are assessed objectively, including whether the contract requires the employee to comply with company policies and states that a breach may lead to disciplinary action.
In Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50 (‘Elisha’), the High Court held that the employment contract incorporated the employer’s disciplinary policies as contractual terms. The contract required compliance with company policies and procedures, and the acceptance clause reinforced that obligation.
A similar approach may apply to an SME employer whose employment contract expressly incorporates a handbook containing a restraint clause, although the clause must still be assessed on its own terms.
The Difference Between Aspirational Statements & Binding Rules
The wording used in a handbook matters. Statements describing workplace culture, values or a “family approach” may express an aspiration rather than a contractual promise. A specific rule or procedural promise is more likely to create a contractual obligation when it is expressed directly and sets out what the employer or employee is required to do.
The distinction appears in Goldman Sachs JBWere Services Pty Limited v Nikolich [2007] FCAFC 120 (‘Nikolich’). The Court treated some statements about workplace health and safety as contractual, while describing the handbook’s harassment provisions as descriptive rather than promissory.
A restraint clause that clearly prohibits a defined post-employment activity is different from a general statement about protecting the business. However, its contractual status still depends on the employment contract and the language used.
Does Acknowledging Receipt Mean Accepting a Restraint?
The Limits of Policy Acknowledgement Forms
Signing a policy acknowledgement usually confirms that the employee received or read the document. It does not, without more, establish contractual acceptance of a new post-employment restraint or non-compete clause.
The signature may be relevant when examining the employment documents as a whole, but it is not conclusive. Confirming that a handbook has been read is different from agreeing to be contractually bound by an employment restraint after the employment ends.
The Requirement for Clear Agreement to Specific Terms
A post-employment restraint requires clear agreement to the specific restraint clause. A general handbook sign-off is unlikely to show that the employee agreed to a new non-compete or other employment restraint merely because the policy included it.
The employment contract or another agreement should record the restraint in clear terms and show that the employee agreed to that particular obligation. Without that agreement, an employer may have difficulty seeking to enforce post-employment restraints in Australia based only on an acknowledgement of receipt.
What Do Non-Contractual Policy Disclaimers Do?
Drafting Effective Policy Disclaimers
An employer can reduce the risk of a workplace policy becoming a contractual term by stating clearly that its policies and procedures do not form part of the employment contract and are not intended to create contractual obligations. The disclaimer should be consistent with the wording used elsewhere in the employment contract and handbook.
The distinction should remain clear throughout the documents. Workplace policies can guide employee conduct and management processes, while any post-employment restraint or other contractual obligation should be set out in the employment contract or a separate agreement.
The Commercial Costs of Ambiguous Documentation
Ambiguous documentation can create uncertainty about whether a workplace policy was intended to bind the employer, the employee, or both. A court may need to examine the wording, purpose and context of the documents, rather than relying only on the label given to the handbook.
That uncertainty can lead to expensive litigation about whether a policy forms part of the employment contract and whether an alleged breach has occurred. An employer may also face difficulty relying on a policy as a workplace guideline if the document contains precise promises, obligations or employee entitlements.
Can an Employer Add a Restraint by Updating a Policy?
The Boundaries of Variation Clauses
A variation clause may allow an employer to update workplace policies during employment. However, that power does not necessarily allow the employer to create a new post-employment restraint, such as a non-compete clause, without the employee’s agreement.
As noted above, Elisha accepted that a contract may incorporate policies as they change over time. The Court also noted that more difficult questions might arise where an employer uses a policy-update power to create substantially new or onerous obligations. A unilateral handbook update is unlikely to support an employment restraint without clear agreement to the specific restraint clause.
Proposed Legislative Changes to Worker Restraints
The Australian Government announced in the 2025–26 Budget that it would ban non-compete clauses for workers earning below the Fair Work Act, 2009 high income threshold. In September 2026, it released an exposure draft Bill that would ban non-competes for employees earning at or below that threshold (currently $190,100), and for all casual employees. The draft also proposes to ban co-worker non-solicitation clauses and prohibit cascading restraints. The reforms are expected to take effect from 2027, following consultation and legislation passing Parliament.
These proposals have not been enacted and do not alter the present contractual position. Until legislation is passed and commenced, an employer considering a non-compete clause still needs to address agreement, incorporation and enforceability under the existing legal framework.
What Can Policies Do During Employment?
Managing Confidential Information & Workplace Conduct
A workplace policy can set expectations for how employees use company data, IT systems and other business resources during employment. It can also address workplace conduct, including professional behaviour, discrimination, harassment and the handling of workplace concerns.
The policy should identify the conduct expected from employees and the systems or information covered. A rule about email use, access to confidential information or dealings with clients may help manage the employment relationship, but it does not by itself create a post-employment restraint.
Directing Employees & Lawful Compliance
An employer can issue lawful and reasonable directions through workplace policies, and employees are generally expected to comply with those directions while they remain employed. These directions may concern work methods, company systems, workplace conduct and compliance with internal procedures.
That obligation is different from a contractual post-employment restraint. A policy may direct an employee not to misuse confidential information or company systems during employment, but a non-compete clause or other employment restraint intended to operate after departure requires separate consideration of its contractual terms and agreement.
When Should a Separate Agreement Be Considered?
Protecting Legitimate Business Interests
A separate contractual agreement, prepared with advice from employment contract lawyers in Sydney about post-employment restraints, may be appropriate where an employer needs to protect trade secrets, confidential information, client relationships or goodwill after employment ends. A non-compete or non-solicitation clause should be closely connected to the employee’s role and limited to what is reasonably necessary to protect that legitimate business interest.
Under section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) (‘Restraints of Trade Act’), a restraint is valid to the extent that it is not against public policy, whether or not it is in severable terms. In practice, its duration, geographic scope and restricted activities still need to be reasonable.
In Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSC 614; [2016] VSCA 334 (‘Peck’), the Victorian courts held that a 12 to 24-month restraint on a CFO was unreasonable, including because it was broader than needed to protect the employer’s confidential information and its length was out of step with the one-month notice that applied during her probation.
Evaluating Practical Options & Commercial Costs
SME employers should select the type of restraint that matches the business interest they need to protect. A targeted non-solicitation or confidentiality clause may be more suitable than a broad non-compete where the concern relates to client relationships or confidential information rather than competition itself.
Drafting a restraint clause involves balancing protection against the cost and uncertainty of enforcement proceedings. Under section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act, where there has been a manifest failure to attempt a reasonable restraint, the Supreme Court of New South Wales may, on application by the person restrained, declare the restraint wholly invalid or valid only to a limited extent. Enforceability is therefore not guaranteed: a carefully limited clause may reduce dispute risk, while an overly broad clause can increase legal costs without securing effective protection.
Conclusion
A staff handbook may become part of an employment contract where the employment contract shows clear contractual intent, but a policy acknowledgement alone may not establish agreement to a specific post-employment restraint. Employers should separate workplace directions from contractual restraints and assess whether a non-compete or other restraint protects a legitimate business interest without creating unnecessary cost or uncertainty.
That distinction makes careful document review worthwhile. Contact the employment contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial to discuss your employment contract, handbook and business objective, so your restraint clause and workplace policies reflect the protection your business actually needs.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.