Chippendale, Sydney · Acting for clients across NSW

Garden Leave Versus Restraints of Trade & When Employers Should Use Paid Leave

Monique Hennessy

Key Takeaways

  • Garden leave: Employees remain paid during notice while their workplace, client and system access is restricted.
  • Express garden leave clause: It clarifies employer rights, payment obligations and employee duties during notice.
  • Post-employment restraints: These are presumed void unless employers prove they reasonably protect legitimate business interests.
  • Act promptly: Delay in enforcing may cause a court to refuse interim relief.

Introduction

Garden leave lets an employer keep an employee away from work and clients on full remuneration during the notice period, while the employment contract and contractual obligations remain in place. A restraint of trade clause operates after employment ends, but enforceability depends on whether the restraint reasonably protects legitimate business interests.

For employers, choosing and combining garden leave and post-employment restraint of trade clauses affects confidential information, client relationships, staff stability, remuneration costs and timing of enforcement. This article explains when each restraint may be useful, how to draft enforceable employment terms, and why an employer seeking to enforce a restraint should act promptly.

Interactive Tool: Check If Your Contracts Protect Your Business When Key Employees Leave

Garden Leave & Restraint of Trade Readiness Checker

Quickly assess if your employment contracts and enforcement approach are set up to protect your business when a key employee exits.

Do your employment contracts contain an express garden leave clause?

✅ Your Contracts and Approach Are Well-Positioned

Your contracts include an express garden leave clause, your restraints are tailored and reviewed, and you understand the need for prompt enforcement. This aligns with best practice and recent case law.

However, employment law is dynamic—periodic review is essential.

Key legal authorities:

  • Express clauses reduce enforceability disputes (Tullett Prebon (Australia) Pty Ltd v Purcell (2008) 175 IR 414; [2008] NSWSC 852)
  • Prompt action is critical (AECI Australia Pty Ltd; Scyne Advisory Business Services Pty Ltd v Heaney [2024] NSWSC 275)
Get Restraint of Trade Legal Advice

⚠️ No Express Garden Leave Clause: Risk of Dispute

Without an express garden leave clause, you risk uncertainty and potential disputes about enforceability. Courts may not imply a right to place an employee on garden leave, especially if the contract requires you to provide work.

Recommendation: Update your contracts to include a clear garden leave provision.

Key legal authority:

  • Tullett Prebon (Australia) Pty Ltd v Purcell (2008) 175 IR 414; [2008] NSWSC 852
Speak to a Lawyer About Updating Your Contracts

⚠️ Generic or Outdated Restraint Clauses: Enforceability Risk

Restraint of trade clauses that are generic or not tailored to the employee’s role, access, and relationships are difficult to enforce. The law presumes such restraints are void unless proven reasonable and necessary.

Recommendation: Review and update restraint clauses to reflect the employee’s current duties and risks.

Key legal authority:

  • DP World Sydney Limited v Guy (2016) NSWSC 1072
Get Tailored Restraint of Trade Advice

❌ Delayed Enforcement: High Risk of Losing Injunctive Relief

Courts have refused injunctions where employers delayed seeking relief during or after garden leave. Acting late—even by a few weeks—can be fatal to your case.

Recommendation: Always seek legal advice and act immediately if you suspect a breach.

Key legal authorities:

  • AECI Australia Pty Ltd
  • Fairfax Media Management Pty Ltd v Harrison
  • Scyne Advisory Business Services Pty Ltd v Heaney [2024] NSWSC 275
Speak to a Lawyer About Enforcing Restraints

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Is Garden Leave & How Does It Differ From a Restraint of Trade for SME Employers?

How Garden Leave Operates During the Employment Notice Period

Garden leave is a period during which an employee does not attend work or perform their usual duties but continues to receive their full salary and contractual benefits for the notice period. The employment contract remains binding, so the employee must continue acting in the employer’s best interests and comply with ongoing contractual obligations.

The employee may also be required to remain available or contactable during the notice period. Depending on the contract, the employer may restrict the employee’s access to the following while the employee remains employed:

  • clients;
  • confidential information; and
  • business systems.

How Restraints of Trade Operate After Employment Ends

A restraint of trade operates after the employment relationship has ended. Depending on its wording, a restraint of trade clause may restrict a former employee from:

  • working for a competitor;
  • soliciting clients; or
  • encouraging other employees to leave.

A restraint of trade is presumed void unless the employer proves that it is reasonable and protects a legitimate business interest. The clause must not go further than necessary to protect interests such as confidential information, customer connections or workforce stability. Its enforceability will depend on the employee’s role, the information accessed and the restraint’s duration and scope.

Creating Distance From Clients & Current Business Information

Garden leave removes a departing employee from the workplace during the notice period while their employment contract remains binding. This can limit access to:

  • confidential information;
  • trade secrets;
  • business systems; and
  • current commercial information.

It can also reduce the employee’s ability to influence clients before employment ends.

The arrangement can be useful where an employee has close client relationships or knowledge of sensitive business material. Keeping the employee away from clients and systems may reduce the risk of that information being used against the employer during the final days of employment.

Managing a Move to a Competitor & Preventing Staff Solicitation

Garden leave can help manage the risk of an employee moving to a competitor. The employee remains away from the workplace and cannot use their remaining access, client relationships or position to:

  • solicit existing clients; or
  • encourage other staff to leave and join a competitor.

These protections may be especially relevant where the employee has influence over customers or colleagues. The employment contract continues during the garden leave period, so the employee remains subject to its applicable obligations, including restrictions on working for another employer.

Weighing the Financial Costs & Handover Disruptions

Garden leave requires the employer to continue paying the employee’s full salary and entitlements, even though the business receives no work output in return. The cost can be substantial where the departing employee has a high salary, and reducing their remuneration may breach the employment contract.

The arrangement can also disrupt a normal handover. A replacement employee may lack the departing employee’s knowledge, advice and assistance, which can cause short-term productivity issues and make it harder to transfer client or operational responsibilities.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Directing an Employee to Take Garden Leave & Essential Contract Clauses

The Importance of an Express Garden Leave Clause in Employment Contracts

An employment contract should include an express garden leave clause before the employer needs to use it, and employers can seek advice from employment contract lawyers in Sydney when drafting or reviewing the clause.

Relying on an implied right can create uncertainty because the position may depend on whether the contract and surrounding circumstances require the employer to provide work. By contrast, a clear clause can address whether work must be provided, how the employee will be paid and which employment obligations continue, reducing the risk of a dispute about enforceability.

Employee Obligations & Remuneration Entitlements During the Leave Period

An employee on garden leave remains bound by the employment contract during the notice period. The employee may be required to:

  • remain available or contactable;
  • avoid working for another employer; and
  • comply with confidentiality, fidelity and any restraint of trade clauses that apply during employment.

The employer must continue paying the employee’s full salary and contractual entitlements. Reducing remuneration or entitlements may breach the employment contract and expose the employer to a claim, including a wrongful dismissal claim. The employee’s lack of work output does not remove the employer’s payment obligations.

When Employers Should Review Their Garden Leave Arrangements

Employers should review garden leave and restraint of trade clauses periodically, rather than assuming an old clause remains enforceable. The review should consider whether any of the following have changed:

  • the employee’s role;
  • their seniority;
  • their client relationships;
  • their confidential information; or
  • their access to commercially sensitive material.

Senior hires and employees with increased commercial exposure may require updated contractual protection. A clause drafted for a junior role may not address the risks associated with a later management or client-facing position, while an overly broad restraint may be difficult to enforce.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Comparing & Combining Garden Leave & Restraints of Trade for Maximum Protection

When Garden Leave May Be More Useful Than a Post-Employment Restraint

Garden leave can be more useful where the immediate concern is protecting clients, confidential information and business systems during an employee’s notice period. The employee remains employed and paid, but can be kept away from clients and current business information while relationships remain warm and information becomes less useful.

This approach may avoid some of the cost and enforcement difficulties associated with a post-employment restraint. Its protection is limited to the employment and notice period, so the contract should clearly address the employee’s ongoing obligations during garden leave.

When Garden Leave Is Not Enough to Protect Commercial Interests

Garden leave may not protect a business once the notice period ends. Client relationships may remain commercially valuable, and confidential information may continue to create a risk after the employee leaves.

A post-employment restraint may be needed where the employee could use those relationships or information for a competitor. A broad clause may be difficult to enforce if the employee’s role and access to information do not justify its duration or scope.

Protecting Different Stages of an Employee’s Departure

Garden leave and restraint of trade clauses can address different periods of an employee’s departure. Garden leave protects the employer during the notice period, while a post-employment restraint applies after employment ends.

A contract may therefore use garden leave to restrict access to clients, systems and confidential information before termination. A restraint of trade clause may then protect customer connections, confidential information or workforce stability after the employment relationship has ended. Each restriction must still be considered against the interests it is intended to protect.

Calculating Restraint Timeframes Following a Period of Garden Leave

A period of garden leave does not necessarily reduce the length of a post-employment restraint. The wording of the clause and the contract’s meaning determine when the restraint period starts.

In DP World Sydney Limited v Guy (2016) NSWSC 1072 (‘DP World‘), the restraint was expressed to operate for three months from the date of termination. The Supreme Court of New South Wales held that the three-month period began when employment ended after garden leave, rather than when garden leave started.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Key Legal Lessons for Employers Enforcing Restraints & Garden Leave

Why Delaying Legal Action During Garden Leave Can Be Fatal

Employers should act promptly when an employee may breach a restraint of trade clause during garden leave. Courts have criticised delay in several cases:

Understanding How Courts Apply the Restraint of Trade Doctrine

The restraint of trade doctrine can also apply to restrictions imposed during garden leave, not only after employment ends. In Tullett Prebon (Australia) Pty Ltd v Purcell (2008) 175 IR 414; [2008] NSWSC 852 (‘Tullett Prebon‘), the court held that a restraint operating during employment, including garden leave, still had to be justified by reasonableness. A garden leave clause cannot be used to impose a broader restraint than the employer could reasonably enforce after employment ends.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Conclusion

Garden leave protects an employer during the notice period, while a restraint of trade clause addresses risks after employment ends. Both measures depend on carefully drafted employment terms, a legitimate business interest and prompt action where an employer seeks to enforce a restraint.

For employers reviewing these arrangements, contact the restraint of trade lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial to discuss your employment contracts and restraint of trade clauses. Our lawyers can help assess whether your garden leave terms are clear, whether a restraint is likely to be enforceable, and what steps may help protect client connections and confidential information during an employee’s departure.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

JUMP TO...

JUMP TO...

Table of Contents

GET IN TOUCH

Talk it through with a senior lawyer.

Tell us what’s happening in your business. We’ll discuss your situation and outline next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Client reviews

What our clients say

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Insights

Plain-English notes & legal insights for business owners

Contact

Request a consultation

An obligation-free 15-minute conversation about your matter. We’ll explain where you stand and what your next steps could be.

Phone

Office

Level 5, The Brewery, 5 Central Park Avenue, Chippendale.
Working with clients across Greater Sydney and NSW.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

FIXED-FEE REVIEW
Privacy Policy Truth Check

Before 10 December 2026

Is your privacy policy telling the truth?

New privacy policy rules for automated decision-making start on 10 December 2026. Our fixed-fee Truth Check reviews your policy against how your business actually operates, for $1,290 + GST.

Engagements confirmed by 10 December 2026 include the automated decision-making check.