Introduction
A restraint clause may look comprehensive on paper, but that doesn’t necessarily make it enforceable. A restriction that is appropriate for a senior executive may be far too broad for a salesperson or technical employee with very different responsibilities.
For SME employers, the practical starting point is to identify the business risk created by the employee’s departure and draft the restraint around that risk. The restricted activities, duration and geographic area should reflect the employee’s role, access to confidential information and influence over clients or other employees. In NSW, that approach also needs to operate consistently with the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW).
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Restraint Clause Is Likely Enforceable
Employment Restraint Clause Enforceability Checker
Find out if your employment restraint clause is likely to be enforceable under NSW law.
1 of 4 | What is the main business interest you are seeking to protect with the restraint?
2 of 4 | How is the restraint clause tailored to the employee’s actual role and risks?
3 of 4 | What is the duration of the post-employment restraint?
4 of 4 | How is the geographical area of the restraint defined?
✅ Likely Enforceable
- Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
- Tullett Prebon (Australia) Pty Ltd v Simon Purcell [2008] NSWSC 852
⚠️ May Be Unenforceable – Needs Review
- Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSCA 334
- Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
❌ Unlikely to Be Enforceable
- Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
- Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSCA 334
⚖️ Complex or Unusual Scenario – Specialist Review Needed
- Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
What Makes an Employment Restraint Enforceable?
Identifying a Legitimate Business Interest
Before drafting the restraint, identify what the business actually needs to protect. That may include important customer relationships, goodwill, trade secrets, confidential information or workforce connections.
A restraint shouldn’t be included simply because the employer wants to prevent future competition. As recognised in Tullett Prebon (Australia) Pty Ltd v Simon Purcell [2008] NSWSC 852, an employer needs a legitimate business interest that requires protection.
The relevant interest will depend on the employee’s real position in the business, including who they deal with, what information they can access and how much influence they have over clients or other employees.
Tailoring the Restraint to the Risk Being Protected
The restraint clause should address the specific commercial risk created by the employee’s departure and go no further than reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interest.
Different roles may require different restrictions. An executive with access to strategic information may require different restrictions from:
- a sales employee whose main influence arises through customer relationships; or
- a technical employee with access to confidential systems and trade secrets.
A non-compete clause may be difficult to justify where a narrower non-solicitation clause would address the identified risk.
How to Define Restraint Scope, Duration & Geography
Defining the Restricted Activities
The clause should clearly identify what the employee is restricted from doing after employment ends. Depending on the business risk, that might include working for a competitor, soliciting clients, accepting work from certain clients, recruiting employees or using confidential information.
Each restriction should have a reason. A clause that prevents an employee from working for almost any competing business may be difficult to justify where the real concern is limited to a handful of client relationships or confidential information. In that situation, a narrower restriction may provide more targeted protection.
Connecting the Restrictions to the Employee’s Role
The drafting should reflect what the employee actually does rather than relying only on their job title. Consider which clients they manage, what commercial decisions they influence, what confidential information they can access and whether they supervise or recruit other employees.
A restriction should then focus on the activities that create the real risk. For example, an employee responsible for only one client segment may not need to be prevented from dealing with every customer of the business. Similarly, a restraint aimed at confidential information shouldn’t prevent work that has no realistic connection with that information.
Matching the Duration to the Business Interest
The restraint period should reflect how long the identified business risk is likely to remain significant. There isn’t a standard period that works for every employee.
For client relationships, one practical question may be how long the business reasonably needs to introduce a replacement and allow that person to establish their own relationship with the client. For confidential information, the relevant period may instead depend on how quickly that information becomes outdated or loses commercial value.
Employers should document why the selected period is appropriate for the role and risk. That reasoning can be more useful than relying on the same three, six or twelve-month period across every employment contract.
Matching the Geographic Restraint to the Employee’s Real Market
Geography should reflect where the employee actually creates a competitive or relationship risk. That may be the area where they manage clients, conduct business or use commercially sensitive information.
A simple kilometre radius won’t always make sense. A salesperson may work from Sydney but manage clients nationally, while another employee may have responsibilities limited to one market despite working for a business with operations across Australia.
The drafting should therefore focus on the employee’s genuine area of influence rather than automatically copying the employer’s entire operating footprint into the restraint.
Why One Restraint Shouldn’t Fit Every Employee
Why SME Employers Must Avoid Using the Same Restraint for Every Employee
Using one restraint clause across the entire workforce may be convenient, but it can create a mismatch between the restriction and the commercial risk.
When reviewing a restraint, employers should consider the employee’s seniority, decision-making authority, client influence, access to confidential information and relationships with other employees. The clause should then be adjusted to reflect those factors rather than simply reproducing the same non-compete, period and geographical area in every employment contract.
Choosing Between Non-Compete & Non-Solicitation Restrictions
The type of restraint should match the particular risk. A non-compete clause may be appropriate where working for a competitor creates a risk that narrower protections can’t adequately address. A non-solicitation clause may be more targeted where the main concern is client or workforce relationships.
Employers shouldn’t assume that the broader clause provides better protection. Where the commercial risk can be addressed through a narrower restriction, that may be easier to justify.
Implementing a Cascading Restraint Clause
A cascading clause gives the contract alternative restraint periods, areas or other limits, with the intention that a narrower option may operate if a broader one cannot.
That doesn’t mean employers should insert as many combinations as possible. Too many alternatives can make the clause difficult to understand and may create uncertainty about what the employee is actually agreeing to. The better approach is to use cascading drafting deliberately and ensure the alternatives still reflect the particular role and business risk.
Common Restraint Drafting Mistakes
Using Restrictions That Are Broader Than the Identified Risk
A restraint of trade clause should address the employer’s actual legitimate interest, not restrict every form of work with a competitor. Unclear wording, broad restricted activities or excessive geographic coverage may prevent an employee from working in areas where their confidential information, client relationships or business influence are irrelevant.
In Just Group Limited v Peck [2016] VSCA 334 (‘Just Group‘), the Victorian Court of Appeal refused to enforce a restraint that would have stopped the company’s former chief financial officer from joining a competitor, in part because the confidential information she held was not relevant to the new role. The Court also declined to cut words out of the clause to save it. Victoria has no equivalent of the NSW Restraints of Trade Act, and NSW courts have some power under that Act to enforce a restraint only to the extent it is reasonable. Even so, an employer shouldn’t assume that a court will narrow an unreasonable non-compete clause or remove problematic parts after a dispute arises.
Using Generic or Outdated Employment Contracts
A standard employment contract may not reflect the employee’s seniority, responsibilities, client connections, confidential information or actual area of influence, so employers may benefit from restraint of trade lawyers reviewing their clauses.
Applying the same restraint clause to an executive, sales employee and technical employee can produce restrictions that don’t match the business risk.
An old restraint clause may also fail to reflect changes in the business or the employee’s role. In that case, the employer should check whether the restricted activities, duration and geographic area still relate to the legitimate interest the restraint is intended to protect.
Triggers for Reviewing Existing Restraint Clauses
An existing restraint clause should be reviewed when the employee’s role or the business risk changes. Relevant triggers include:
- a promotion into an executive or management role;
- new responsibilities or access to confidential information;
- changes to client portfolios or customer influence;
- business expansion into new locations or markets; and
- an updated employment agreement.
A promotion may give an employee access to strategic information or major client relationships that weren’t part of the original role. The previous restraint clause may no longer reflect those responsibilities.
When SME Employers Should Get Restraint Clauses Reviewed
Employers should consider a restraint review when preparing a new contract, hiring a senior employee or making a material change to an employee’s role. Review is also appropriate where a restraint has been carried forward for years without checking whether it still addresses the business’s actual risks.
Connected Legal can help business owners review the clause against the employee’s role, confidential information, client relationships, restricted activities, duration and geographic area. Obtaining legal advice before a contract is signed or changed can help identify drafting issues before the employer needs to enforce restraint clauses.
Financial Exposure & Loss of Key Clients
An unenforceable restraint can leave an employer exposed to losses that may be difficult to calculate. A former employee may, for example, take valuable intellectual property or use customer connections to compete.
As a result, the employer may lose:
- transactions;
- goodwill;
- clients; and
- market share.
The financial impact may extend beyond an ordinary breach of contract claim. Losses involving goodwill and customer connections can be hard to quantify, because they depend on assumptions about which clients the employee would have retained or won.
A carefully drafted restraint clause may help an employer seek to prevent the conduct rather than rely only on damages after the loss occurs.
Reputational Damage & Business Disruption
A poorly drafted restraint can also disrupt the employer’s business when it can’t protect customer connections, confidential information or workforce connections from a competitor. The departure of an employee with strong customer relationships may:
- destabilise client management;
- require rapid reassignment of accounts; and
- place pressure on other employees.
A restraint clause directed at retaining current employees must protect a recognised staff connection interest, rather than prevent an employee from leaving. If former employees recruit colleagues or transfer client relationships to a competitor, the employer may face disruption to its workforce and business operations, as well as damage to goodwill.
Conclusion
An enforceable employment restraint should reflect the employee’s actual role, access, relationships and influence. Its restricted activities, duration and geographic area should connect to the business interest being protected, rather than rely on a standard formula that may restrict work unnecessarily.
With those points in mind, contact the restraint of trade lawyers at Connected Legal + Commercial to review your employment contracts and restraint clauses. Our employment lawyers can help identify whether the post-employment restrictions match the employee’s responsibilities and the risks facing your business, including after a promotion or material role change.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.