Chippendale, Sydney · Acting for clients across NSW

Choosing Between Non-Compete & Non-Solicitation Clauses to Best Protect Your Business

Monique Hennessy

Key Takeaways

  • Match the restraint to risk: Use non-solicitation to protect client or staff relationships without blocking industry employment.
  • Use non-compete cautiously: Reserve it for risks narrower restrictions cannot adequately protect, such as confidential information.
  • Prove a legitimate interest: Any restraint must protect an identifiable interest and go no further than reasonably necessary.
  • Proposed reforms: Draft legislation released 7 September 2026 proposes banning non-competes below $190,100.

Introduction

Australian employers often use a non-compete clause or non-solicitation clause to protect client relationships, confidential information and staff connections after employment ends. The choice between non-compete and non-solicitation clauses depends on the legitimate business interest at risk, the employee’s role and whether a narrower restraint can provide adequate protection.

Draft Commonwealth legislation released in September 2026 proposes significant changes to post-employment restraints, including restrictions affecting non-compete clauses. The proposed reforms are not yet operative law, so employers should continue assessing existing restraints under the current law while monitoring the reform process.

Interactive Tool: See Which Non-Compete or Non-Solicitation Clause Suits Your Business

Non-Compete vs Non-Solicitation Clause Selector

Find out which restraint clause best protects your business and is most likely to be enforceable under Australian law.

What is your main concern if a key employee leaves your business?

What level of access did the employee have?

✅ A Non-Solicitation Clause May Suit Your Needs

Based on your answers, a non-solicitation clause may be the most appropriate and enforceable restraint. This clause can protect your business by preventing a former employee from approaching or enticing clients, customers, suppliers or staff to move their business or employment. Australian courts are more likely to uphold a targeted non-solicitation clause that matches the actual business risk and the employee’s role.

Remember, the clause should be tailored to cover only those relationships the employee actually developed, and not every client or staff member.

For further guidance, seek advice on drafting a clause that is clear, limited and connected to your legitimate business interests.
  • Lindner v Murdock’s Garage (1950) 83 CLR 628
  • Barrett & Ors v Ecco Personnel Pty Ltd [1998] NSWSC 545
Get Restraint of Trade Legal Advice

⚖️ Consider a Non-Compete Clause for Broader Protection

Your responses indicate that a non-compete clause may be justified, especially if the employee had access to highly sensitive confidential information or held a senior position with strategic influence. Non-compete clauses can restrict a former employee from working for a competitor or starting a similar business, but they are closely scrutinised by Australian courts and must be limited to what is reasonably necessary to protect your business interests.

Ensure the clause is not broader than needed, and consider whether a non-solicitation clause would suffice for less senior staff or where the risk is limited to client relationships.
  • Lindner v Murdock’s Garage (1950) 83 CLR 628
Speak to a Lawyer About Restraint Clauses

❌ Preventing Competition Alone Is Not Enforceable

Australian law does not allow restraint clauses simply to prevent ordinary competition. You must identify a legitimate business interest—such as client relationships, confidential information, or trade secrets—to justify a restraint. Courts will not enforce a clause that only aims to keep a former employee out of the market or prevent them from using general skills and experience.

Review your business risks and consider whether a more targeted clause is appropriate.
  • Lindner v Murdock’s Garage (1950) 83 CLR 628
Get Restraint of Trade Legal Advice

⚠️ A Restraint Clause May Not Be Justified

If the employee had no special access to clients, confidential information or staff, a restraint clause is unlikely to be enforceable. Australian courts require a clear connection between the restraint and a legitimate business interest. Overly broad or unnecessary clauses may be struck down and could expose your business to legal costs.

Consider reviewing your employment agreements to ensure restraints are only used where genuinely needed.
  • Lindner v Murdock’s Garage (1950) 83 CLR 628
Speak to a Lawyer About Your Employment Contracts

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Understanding Non-Compete & Non-Solicitation Clauses for Your Australian Business

What a Non-Compete Clause Restricts

A non-compete clause restricts a former employee from working for a competitor or starting a similar business after employment ends. The restraint usually applies for a defined period and within a specified geographic area.

The clause can affect an employee’s ability to continue working in the same industry. Because non-compete clauses restrict competition and may limit a person’s ability to earn a living, Australian courts scrutinise them closely. An employer therefore needs a legitimate business interest and a restraint that goes no further than reasonably necessary to protect it.

What a Non-Solicitation Clause Restricts

A non-solicitation clause targets conduct rather than employment generally. It may prevent a former employee from directly or indirectly approaching clients, customers, suppliers or employees to move their business or employment to the former employee’s new enterprise.

A non-solicitation clause usually allows the former employee to continue working for a competitor while restricting particular conduct involving protected relationships. Whether the clause is breached where a client makes the first approach depends on the wording of the restraint and what the former employee does in response. A separate non-dealing clause may go further by restricting dealings even where the client initiates contact.

Client & Employee Non-Solicitation Clauses

Client non-solicitation clauses seek to protect relationships with clients or customers, particularly where an employee has developed significant influence or become the main point of contact for the business.

Co-worker non-solicitation clauses seek to restrict a former employee from recruiting or encouraging colleagues to leave. Under the current law, enforceability depends on the circumstances, the legitimate business interest being protected and whether the restriction is reasonably necessary. Proposed Commonwealth reforms may change the treatment of these clauses if enacted.

Key Differences Between Non-Compete & Non-Solicitation for Australian Employers

The main difference between non-compete and non-solicitation clauses is the conduct they restrict:

  • A non-compete clause restricts working for a competitor or operating a similar business.
  • A non-solicitation clause restricts approaching defined clients, customers, suppliers or employees.
  • A non-compete clause can affect an employee’s ability to remain in the same industry.
  • A non-solicitation clause usually allows continued employment while protecting identified business connections.

A professional services firm may have a concern about a departing account manager taking client relationships, rather than joining a competitor itself. A targeted non-solicitation clause may address that concern without imposing the wider restriction of a non-compete clause.

How Are the Rules for Non-Competes Changing for Australian Businesses?

Draft Commonwealth legislation released in September 2026 proposes significant changes to post-employment restraints, including a proposed non-compete restriction linked to the Fair Work Act high-income threshold of $190,100 for 2026–27.

The draft also addresses matters including co-worker non-solicitation clauses, cascading restraints, no-poach arrangements and wage-fixing arrangements. These proposals are not yet operative law, and employers should continue applying the current restraint-of-trade framework unless and until legislation is enacted and commences.

Client & Customer Relationships

Established client and customer relationships can be a legitimate business interest because they contribute to the goodwill of your business. The case for protection is stronger where an employee has regular contact with clients, builds trust over time, and becomes the “face” of the business.

A restraint may be relevant where the employee could use personal knowledge of clients or the influence developed during employment to divert business. For a professional services firm, this may apply to a senior adviser who manages long-standing client relationships. The restraint still needs to protect those relationships without extending beyond what the business reasonably needs.

Confidential Information & Trade Secrets

Confidential information and trade secrets may justify a restraint where an employee has access to sensitive material that could harm the business if used by a competitor. This can include:

  • secret processes;
  • pricing strategies;
  • client information;
  • bids; and
  • operational methods.

The information must go beyond the employee’s ordinary skills, experience and general industry knowledge. A restraint cannot prevent an employee from using their own mental and manual abilities to earn a living. Employers should identify the specific information at risk before relying on a non-compete clause.

Key Employees & Workforce Connections

A business may have a legitimate interest in protecting workforce relationships where a departing employee has sufficient influence over colleagues to create a real risk of staff solicitation or coordinated departures.

A non-solicitation clause may address conduct such as actively encouraging employees to leave and join another business. The restriction should reflect the departing employee’s actual influence and relationships rather than simply the employer’s investment in recruiting or training its workforce.

Why Preventing Competition Alone Is Not Enough

Preventing ordinary competition isn’t, by itself, a legitimate business interest. An employer can’t restrain a former employee simply because they may join a competitor, start a competing business or use their general skills and experience elsewhere.

As the High Court recognised in Lindner v Murdock’s Garage (1950) 83 CLR 628, the employer must identify something the law permits it to protect, such as confidential information, trade secrets or established customer relationships. The restraint must then go no further than reasonably necessary to protect that interest.

The Greater Restriction on an Employee’s Ability to Work

A non-compete clause can prevent a former employee from working for a competitor or operating a similar business across a defined area and period. That broad restriction can affect career mobility and the person’s ability to earn a living in their chosen field.

Courts examine non-compete clauses closely because the restraint of trade may extend beyond particular clients, staff or information. A clause applying to a junior employee with no client influence or access to sensitive information may be difficult to justify.

Why Narrower Protections Matter

A targeted restraint can protect a defined business interest while allowing the former employee to continue working in the industry. A non-solicitation clause may address the risk of client diversion or staff poaching without preventing all competitive employment.

Courts are more likely to examine whether the restriction matches the risk identified by the employer. If protecting particular client relationships is enough, a broad non-compete clause may go further than reasonably necessary. The appropriate restraint depends on the employee’s role, relationships and access to confidential information.

Protecting Established Client Relationships

A non-solicitation clause may be enough where the main risk is the loss of established client relationships, rather than competition across the whole market. This can apply to people such as:

  • sales managers;
  • brokers; and
  • senior client-facing employees who have regular contact with customers and may become the “face” of the business.

The clause can target conduct such as approaching, canvassing or enticing defined clients to move their business. However, it should reflect the relationships the employee actually developed, rather than covering every customer of the business.

A restriction that extends beyond the employer’s genuine commercial risk may be difficult to enforce.

Preventing Former Employees From Soliciting Staff

A non-solicitation clause can also protect a business from former employees encouraging colleagues to leave and join them elsewhere. This may matter where the employer has invested substantial time and resources in training staff or building a specialised team.

The restriction can focus on employees or contractors with whom the departing person worked or had meaningful dealings. Importantly, it need not prevent the former employee from working in the same industry. That narrower approach may protect workforce stability while allowing the person to continue their employment or business activities.

Allowing Competition While Protecting Business Connections

A non-solicitation clause allows a former employee to work for a competitor or establish a competing business, subject to restrictions on defined conduct. In doing so, it can protect client relationships, staff connections and goodwill without preventing competition across the entire market.

The approach may suit a technology, marketing or professional services business where the concern is that a departing manager will transfer specific relationships rather than use information to compete generally. The clause still needs to be clear, limited and connected to a legitimate business interest. A targeted restraint is not automatically enforceable merely because it is narrower than a non-compete clause.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

When Might an Australian Employer Consider a Non-Compete Clause?

When Non-Solicitation Does Not Address the Identified Risk

A non-solicitation clause may not address the risk where a former employee could harm the business without directly approaching clients, suppliers or staff. In that situation, a non-compete clause may be considered where the employee could use their knowledge of the employer’s business, customer relationships or confidential methods to undermine the employer’s position through competing work.

The employer still needs to identify a legitimate business interest capable of protection. A restraint can’t be imposed only to prevent ordinary competition or to stop a former employee from using their general skills and knowledge.

Protecting Highly Sensitive Confidential Information

Highly sensitive confidential information may support a restraint where its use by a competitor could cause genuine commercial harm. This may include secret processes, pricing structures, tender information, client strategies or long-term development plans.

However, employers should also consider whether confidentiality obligations, intellectual property protections or a narrower restraint can adequately address the risk. A non-compete may be considered where those protections don’t sufficiently address the particular commercial risk, but it should still be limited to what is reasonably necessary.

Senior Employees With Significant Business Knowledge or Influence

Senior employees may present a stronger case for a non-compete where their role gives them close knowledge of the business or influence over clients, suppliers or staff. This may include:

  • a C-suite executive;
  • a senior project manager; or
  • a senior employee responsible for tender strategies, pricing or major customer relationships.

However, seniority alone doesn’t justify a restraint clause. The employer should assess the employee’s actual duties, access to confidential information and relationships before deciding whether a non-compete is reasonably necessary. A broad restraint may still be difficult to enforce if a narrower non-solicitation clause would adequately protect the business.

p patterns into the canvas.

How Should Australian Employers Choose Between Non-Compete & Non-Solicitation?

Identify the Specific Business Risk

Start by identifying the conduct that could harm your business after an employee leaves. The concern may involve client loss, staff poaching or the misuse of strategic information.

The restraint should respond to the actual risk, rather than restrict competition as a separate goal. For example:

  • A professional services firm may be concerned about a senior adviser transferring established client relationships.
  • A technology business may instead be concerned about an executive using confidential pricing, product or development information for a competing business.

Identify the Legitimate Business Interest

An employer should identify the specific proprietary asset that requires protection before drafting a restraint clause. Recognised interests may include:

  • client relationships;
  • goodwill;
  • confidential information;
  • trade secrets; and
  • workforce connections.

A non-compete clause can’t be justified only because an employer doesn’t want a former employee to join a competitor. The restraint must protect a legitimate business interest and provide no more protection than the business reasonably needs.

Consider Whether a Narrower Restraint Is Sufficient

Ask whether a non-solicitation clause would address the identified risk without preventing the former employee from working in the same industry. This may be suitable where the concern is limited to approaching identified clients, suppliers or former colleagues.

For example, a sales manager who has built strong relationships with particular customers may present a client-diversion risk, rather than a risk from competition across the whole market. A targeted non-solicitation clause may address that concern while allowing the manager to continue working elsewhere.

Tailor the Clause to the Employee’s Role

A single restraint clause shouldn’t be used for every employee. The employee’s seniority, duties, client influence and access to confidential information affect the type and scope of restraint that may be reasonably necessary, so restraint of trade lawyers in Sydney can help tailor the clause to the role.

A senior executive with access to strategic information and important client relationships may present a very different risk from an employee with limited client contact or access to sensitive information. Employment contracts should reflect those differences and be reviewed when an employee’s responsibilities materially change.

Using Different Restraints for Different Business Risks

Different roles may justify different restraint clauses. For example:

  • A non-compete clause may be considered for an executive with close knowledge of confidential business methods.
  • A non-solicitation clause may address the risk presented by a client-facing employee.

A marketing business may need to protect a departing account manager’s client relationships without preventing that person from working for another marketing firm. The appropriate restraint depends on the business interest and the employee’s connection to it.

Avoiding Unnecessary Overlap

Each clause should have a clear purpose and defined scope. Piling a broad non-compete clause on top of non-solicitation, confidentiality and other related clauses may create uncertainty about what the agreement is intended to protect.

The employer should distinguish between restrictions on:

  • working for a competitor;
  • approaching clients or staff; and
  • using confidential information.

Clear drafting helps show that the restraint is directed at a specific business risk, rather than designed to prevent all future competition.

Why Overly Broad Restraints Can Create Commercial Risk

A restraint that goes further than the business reasonably needs may be difficult to enforce when an employee leaves. That can expose the employer to lost client relationships, misuse of confidential information, business disruption and legal costs if the clause does not provide the protection expected.

Reviewing restraints when an employee is hired, promoted or given materially different responsibilities can help keep the contract aligned with the actual business risk rather than waiting until a dispute arises.

p patterns into the canvas.

Conclusion

The choice between a non-compete clause and a non-solicitation clause depends on the legitimate business interest your organisation needs to protect, the employee’s role and the risk involved. A targeted non-solicitation clause may address client or workforce relationship risks, while a non-compete clause may be considered where confidential information or broader competitive harm cannot be adequately protected another way.

With proposed Commonwealth reforms now subject to consultation until 2 October 2026, employers should review their employment agreements and avoid relying on broad restraints without a clear justification. Contact the restraint of trade lawyers at Connected Legal + Commercial in Sydney to review your restraint clauses and obtain practical advice tailored to your business, employees and commercial risks.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

JUMP TO...

JUMP TO...

Table of Contents

GET IN TOUCH

Talk it through with a senior lawyer.

Tell us what’s happening in your business. We’ll discuss your situation and outline next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Client reviews

What our clients say

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Insights

Plain-English notes & legal insights for business owners

Contact

Request a consultation

An obligation-free 15-minute conversation about your matter. We’ll explain where you stand and what your next steps could be.

Phone

Office

Level 5, The Brewery, 5 Central Park Avenue, Chippendale.
Working with clients across Greater Sydney and NSW.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

FIXED-FEE REVIEW
Privacy Policy Truth Check

Before 10 December 2026

Is your privacy policy telling the truth?

New privacy policy rules for automated decision-making start on 10 December 2026. Our fixed-fee Truth Check reviews your policy against how your business actually operates, for $1,290 + GST.

Engagements confirmed by 10 December 2026 include the automated decision-making check.