Introduction
A former employee joining a competitor doesn’t automatically mean your business can enforce a restraint of trade clause. The restraint needs to protect something the business can legitimately protect, such as an important customer relationship or genuinely confidential information, rather than simply preventing competition.
For SME employers, the practical question is what business risk the employee’s departure creates. That means looking at who they dealt with, what information they could access and how much influence they had over clients, staff or commercial decisions. Identifying those interests early can help employers draft more targeted restraints and assess whether an existing clause is likely to provide meaningful protection.
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Restraint Clause Protects a Legitimate Business Interest
Legitimate Business Interest Checker for Restraint Clauses
Find out if your post-employment restraint protects a legitimate business interest—before you risk enforceability or exposure.
What is the main interest your restraint clause is intended to protect?
Can you identify a specific risk linked to the employee’s actual role?
Is the restraint limited to what is reasonably necessary to protect the identified interest?
✅ Likely Legitimate Business Interest Identified
Your restraint appears to target a specific, protectable business interest—such as customer connections or confidential information—linked to the employee’s actual role.
Courts are more likely to enforce a clause that is narrowly tailored to genuine risks, supported by clear evidence of the employee’s influence, access, or responsibilities.
For best results, ensure your records document the interest, risk, and connection to the employee’s duties.
Key authorities:
Section 333ZG of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (proposed)
2nd Chapter Pty Ltd & Ors v Sealey & Ors (No 2) [2024] VSC 672; 336 IR 1
McMurchy v Employsure Pty Ltd; Kumaran v Employsure Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCA 201
AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No 4) [2024] FCA 1110
❌ No Legitimate Business Interest Identified
A restraint clause that only prevents ordinary competition or is not tied to a specific commercial risk is unlikely to be enforceable.
Courts will not uphold a restraint that covers all clients, information, or staff without evidence of a genuine business interest arising from the employee’s actual role.
Review your clause and supporting records to ensure you can identify and document a protectable interest.
Key authorities:
2nd Chapter Pty Ltd & Ors v Sealey & Ors (No 2) [2024] VSC 672; 336 IR 1
AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No 4) [2024] FCA 1110
⚠️ Restraint May Be Too Broad
If your restraint clause applies to all clients, information, or staff regardless of the employee’s actual involvement, it may be vulnerable to challenge.
Court may refuse to enforce a clause that is broader than necessary, even if some parts are valid.
Tailor your clause to the employee’s real connections, influence, and access for the best chance of enforceability.
Key authorities:
2nd Chapter Pty Ltd & Ors v Sealey & Ors (No 2) [2024] VSC 672; 336 IR 1
AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No 4) [2024] FCA 1110
What Is a Legitimate Business Interest?
What Business Interests Can an Employer Legitimately Protect?
A restraint is more likely to be enforceable where it protects a specific business interest arising from the employment relationship. Common examples include confidential information, trade secrets and valuable customer connections.
What an employer generally can't protect is ordinary competition. An employee remains entitled to use their general skills, knowledge and experience in future employment. The fact that those skills make the employee valuable to a competitor doesn't, by itself, give the former employer a legitimate basis for restricting them.
The practical question is therefore not simply whether the employee is joining a competitor. It is what the employee gained access to or developed through their role that creates a genuine commercial risk when they leave.
Goodwill Connected to Customer Relationships
Goodwill in the employment context may arise from personal relationships between an employee and the employer's customers. A legitimate business interest may exist where the employee has gained customers' trust and confidence and could carry their business to a new employer after leaving.
The strength of the relationship matters. A customer connection is more capable of protection where the employee:
- represented the business to the customer;
- influenced the customer's decisions; or
- became the person the customer relied on when managing their affairs.
Comparing Employment Goodwill & Goodwill in a Business Sale
Goodwill is treated differently in an employment restraint than in a business sale. An employer may seek to protect customer connections developed through employment, but the employer isn't automatically entitled to prevent the former employee from competing.
A purchaser of a business may have a broader interest in protecting the goodwill acquired as part of that transaction. 2nd Chapter Pty Ltd & Ors v Sealey & Ors (No 2) [2024] VSC 672; 336 IR 1 ('2nd Chapter'), a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria, distinguished employment restraints from restraints connected with the sale of a business, even where both concerned customer relationships.
Protecting Client Connections & Confidential Information
When Are Customer Relationships a Legitimate Business Interest?
Customer relationships may justify protection where the employee developed enough influence, trust or personal connection that customers could follow them after they leave.
Not every customer interaction creates that risk. A senior adviser who manages a client's affairs over several years may have a very different relationship from a junior employee who had occasional contact with the same customer.
Employers should therefore identify which clients the employee actually dealt with, how significant those relationships were and what influence the employee exercised, rather than treating the entire customer base as equally exposed.
Protecting Confidential Information & Trade Secrets
Confidential information and trade secrets may be legitimate business interests where their use could harm the employer. The information need not always be identified with complete precision when the employment contract is made, but the employer should be able to show that confidential information was expected to exist and could be used to the employer's detriment.
In McMurchy v Employsure Pty Ltd; Kumaran v Employsure Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCA 201 ('McMurchy'), the NSW Court of Appeal recognised an interest in protecting confidential information about the marketing, shortcomings and potential development of the employer's product. Key points about that information included:
- it was obtained through the employee's senior position;
- it related to business strategy; and
- a competitor could use it to the employer's detriment.
A restraint clause aimed at that risk is different from a clause directed only at stopping a former employee from joining a rival.
Can Employers Protect Their Workforce?
Protecting Workforce Stability
Under current law, an employer may have a protectable business interest in maintaining workforce stability where a former employee's conduct creates a specific risk of coordinated departures. For example, in Wilson HTM Investment Group Ltd v Pagliaro [2012] NSWSC 1068, the NSW Supreme Court recognised a legitimate interest in protecting a business from an exodus of its workforce. The focus is not a general wish to stop employees from changing jobs. Rather, it is whether the employee actively encouraged or induced colleagues to leave, and whether that conduct could materially affect the employer's operations.
In McMurchy, the Court of Appeal upheld the finding that Mr McMurchy had materially influenced Mr Kumaran to leave Employsure and join a competitor, ELMO. The Court distinguished this from a situation where an employee helps a colleague find work after that colleague has independently decided to leave. That distinction matters when an employer identifies the business interest a restraint is meant to protect.
Employee Non-Solicitation Restraints
An employee non-solicitation restraint may seek to prevent a departing employee from recruiting, encouraging or inducing current staff to leave. Under current law, any clause should be connected to the specific workforce risk identified, rather than drafted as a broad restriction on ordinary employment discussions.
Employers should also be aware that proposed Competition and Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Banning Unfair Non-Competes) Bill 2026 (Cth) ('Banning Unfair Non-Competes Bill') may affect the future use of employee non-solicitation restraints. Because those reforms have not yet become law, businesses shouldn't assume the existing position has already changed. Any restraint review should consider both the current law and the progress of the proposed reforms.
How to Identify & Document Your Interests
Identify the Risk Before Drafting the Restraint
Before drafting a restraint, identify what the business is actually trying to protect. Is the risk that the employee could take important clients? Use commercially sensitive information? Recruit other key employees?
Record the interest being protected, how the employee's role creates that risk and why a post-employment restriction is considered necessary. A standard clause copied into every contract is less likely to reflect those individual circumstances.
If the position is unclear, restraint of trade lawyers can help assess the employee's role and the commercial interest the business is trying to protect before the contract is finalised.
Connect the Risk to the Employee's Actual Role
Job titles tell only part of the story. Employers should look at what the employee actually does: which clients they manage, what systems and information they can access, what decisions they influence and whether other employees rely on or report to them.
Those facts provide a stronger basis for assessing the business interest than simply describing someone as “senior” or “managerial”. Two employees with similar titles may create very different post-employment risks depending on their actual responsibilities.
Recording Client Information & Employee Commercial Responsibilities
Employers should record the commercial facts supporting the claimed business interest. Relevant records may include:
- the clients the employee managed or regularly dealt with;
- the nature and strength of those client relationships;
- the databases, client lists or systems the employee could access; and
- the employee's responsibility for strategy, sales, products or commercial planning.
Simply labelling information “confidential” won't necessarily establish that it deserves protection. The records should help explain what the information was, how restricted its access was and why its use outside the business could cause commercial harm.
Review the Interest When the Employee's Role Changes
An employee's protectable interests may change after a promotion or a shift in duties. Employers should review the restraint clause and supporting records when an employee:
- gains access to new confidential information;
- takes responsibility for important clients; or
- becomes involved in business strategy.
The review should record the change in role, the new information or relationships involved and the commercial risk created by that change. Seniority alone isn't enough, but changed duties may provide evidence that the employee's access and influence have materially increased.
Make the Restraint No Broader Than the Business Risk
Once the business interest is identified, the restriction should be drafted around that interest.
A client restraint shouldn't automatically apply to every customer of the business if the employee dealt with only a particular group. Likewise, a confidential-information restraint should reflect the type of information the employee actually had access to rather than information they never saw.
Employers should be able to explain the connection between the employee's role, the commercial risk and the restriction imposed. If that connection is difficult to identify, the clause may be broader than the interest the business is genuinely entitled to protect.
Evidence Supporting the Claimed Business Interest
The wording of the employment contract isn't the only evidence relevant to the claimed business interest. Employers should retain material showing the employee's actual influence, access and responsibilities, such as:
- client records;
- role descriptions;
- system permissions;
- reporting lines; and
- commercial documents.
Courts may draw conclusions from the surrounding commercial circumstances, including the nature of client dealings and the information available to the employee. For example, a pattern of clients moving soon after the employee's departure may support an inference of solicitation. Direct evidence of misuse may assist, but the employer should not rely on the restraint clause alone to establish that the interest exists.
Consequences of Failing to Identify an Interest
Facing Financial Exposure & Lost Business Opportunities
If a restraint doesn't protect a legitimate business interest, an employer may discover that it has little practical protection after a key employee leaves. The consequences can include lost clients, reduced revenue, disruption to customer relationships and the cost of rebuilding those connections.
AEI Insurance Group Pty Ltd v Martin (No 4) [2024] FCA 1110 illustrates how significant customer movements can translate into substantial commercial loss. The broader lesson is that an employer should identify and document the interest before a dispute occurs rather than relying on a restraint clause alone after clients have already moved.
These issues may also overlap with broader protection of goodwill and commercial assets, which Connected Legal's business and commercial lawyers can advise on where appropriate.
Managing Reputational Damage & Disruption to Operations
A poorly supported restraint clause may not prevent a former employee from encouraging colleagues to leave or taking customer relationships to a competitor. That can disrupt staffing, place pressure on remaining employees and affect how the business manages client services during the employee's departure. In McMurchy, for example, the departing manager gave the competitor the names of sales employees it could approach and approached a colleague about a role.
The employee's conduct and influence matter, as the workforce stability discussion above explains. A business relying on a restraint clause should be able to show the specific workforce risk it was intended to address.
Conclusion
A restraint of trade clause is more likely to be enforceable when it protects an identifiable legitimate business interest, such as customer connections or genuinely confidential information, rather than ordinary competition. Employers should connect that interest to the employee's actual role and retain evidence of client responsibilities, information access and the commercial risk the post-employment restraint addresses.
With that framework in mind, review your employment contracts and supporting records before relying on a restraint clause or responding to a departure. Contact Connected Legal + Commercial's restraint of trade lawyers to discuss your business interests, documentation and post-employment restraints, assess the position and plan appropriate next steps.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.