Chippendale, Sydney · Acting for clients across NSW

What Is a Cascading Restraint Clause & How Does It Protect Employers?

Monique Hennessy

Key Takeaways

  • Separate restraint options: A cascading clause offers alternative periods, areas and activities instead of one broad restriction.
  • Reasonable drafting: Each option must be clear, severable and reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest.
  • No automatic protection: If even the narrowest option is unreasonable, the entire restraint may fail.
  • 2027 reform risk: Proposed Commonwealth reforms may change the position, so check the final law first.

Introduction

A cascading restraint clause in an employment contract sets out multiple alternatives for the restraint period, geographic area and restricted activities. Each alternative is intended to operate as a separate, severable provision, allowing an employer to seek enforcement of a narrower restraint if a broader option is unreasonable.

For Australian employers, this drafting mechanism may help protect legitimate business interests such as confidential information, trade secrets and client connections, but it isn’t an automatic route to enforceability. The discussion covers how cascading clauses operate, the limits of severance, lessons from Hanna v OAMPS Insurance Brokers Ltd [2010] NSWCA 267 (‘Hanna v OAMPS‘), and proposed Commonwealth reforms expected to take effect from 2027.

Interactive Tool: See If Your Cascading Restraint Clause Will Hold Up

Cascading Restraint Clause Enforceability Checker

Quickly assess if your employment contract’s cascading restraint clause is likely to protect your business interests under NSW law.

Are you an employer seeking to enforce a restraint clause against a former employee?

Does the restraint clause clearly state each alternative period, area, and restricted activity as separate, independent provisions?

Is the narrowest restraint (shortest period, smallest area, most limited activity) reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest?

✅ Your Cascading Restraint Clause Is Likely Enforceable

Based on your answers, your cascading restraint clause is likely to be enforceable under NSW law. Each alternative is clear, independent, and the narrowest option is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest.

As confirmed in Hanna v OAMPS Insurance Brokers Ltd [2010] NSWCA 267, courts may uphold well-drafted cascading clauses that protect legitimate interests and are proportionate to the employee’s role.

However, enforceability always depends on the specific facts and evidence. For tailored advice or to strengthen your contract, consult an employment lawyer.

  • Hanna v OAMPS Insurance Brokers Ltd [2010] NSWCA 267
  • Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
Speak to a Restraint of Trade Lawyer

⚠️ Your Clause May Be at Risk of Being Unenforceable

Your answers suggest that the restraint clause may be at risk of being unenforceable. Courts require each alternative in a cascade to be clear, separate, and capable of being severed. Overlapping or ambiguous options, or excessive combinations, may render the clause void for uncertainty, as in Austra Tanks Pty Ltd v Running (1983) 40 ATPR 340.

Consider reviewing and redrafting the clause to ensure each restraint is independent and clearly stated.

  • Austra Tanks Pty Ltd v Running (1983) 40 ATPR 340
  • Bulk Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Excell [2014] TASSC 58
Get Restraint of Trade Advice

❌ The Entire Restraint Clause May Fail

If even the narrowest restraint in your cascade is not reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest, the entire clause may be unenforceable. Courts will not enforce a restraint that is excessive, regardless of how many alternatives are offered.

As highlighted in Just Group Limited v Nicole Peck [2016] VSCA 334 and Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW), a court cannot rewrite the clause to make it reasonable.

It is critical to review and, if needed, renegotiate your restraint clauses.

  • Just Group Limited v Nicole Peck [2016] VSCA 334
  • Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)
Get Help Drafting or Amending Your Contract

⚖️ This Tool Is Designed for Employers

This tool is intended for employers seeking to assess the enforceability of cascading restraint clauses in employment contracts. If you are an employee or another party, you should seek independent legal advice tailored to your circumstances.

Speak to a Restraint of Trade Lawyer

Reducing the Risk of the Entire Restraint Failing

Employers use a cascading restraint to give a court several restraint options, rather than relying on one broad restraint clause. If the widest restraint period, geographic area or restricted activity is unreasonable, a narrower and severable alternative may still be enforceable.

This structure can reduce the risk of losing all post-employment protection when one restraint is rejected. However, it doesn’t guarantee that the court will enforce any option. Each restraint must still be clear, separate and reasonably necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate business interests.

Providing Alternative Levels of Protection

A cascading clause gives an employer different levels of protection for interests such as:

  • goodwill;
  • confidential information;
  • trade secrets; and
  • client connections.

The alternatives may use different restraint periods, geographic areas or restricted activities, allowing the clause to reflect varying levels of risk. A national restraint may be too broad for a role focused on one city, while a shorter local restraint may be reasonable. A targeted non-solicitation clause may also protect client connections without preventing a former employee from working for a competitor.

Adapting Restraints to Different Employee Roles & Risks

A restraint clause should reflect the employee’s role and the business risk involved. Several factors can affect the level of protection that may be reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest, including:

  • seniority;
  • access to confidential information;
  • knowledge of trade secrets; and
  • influence over client connections.

Using the same broad cascading clause for every employee can weaken enforceability. A restraint suitable for an executive with strategic information may be unreasonable for a junior employee with limited client contact. The employment agreement should be calibrated to the actual employment relationship, with advice from restraint of trade lawyers in Sydney where needed.

When an Employee’s Role or Information Access Changes

An employer should review a cascading restraint when an employee’s role evolves or their access to sensitive information increases. A promotion, expanded client responsibility or access to new confidential information may change the business risk that the restraint is intended to address.

The review should consider whether the existing restraint remains proportionate to the employee’s work and the legitimate interest being protected. Changes should be documented in the employment contract or employment agreement, rather than relying on informal discussions after the employment relationship has changed.

When Employment Contracts Are Updated or Restraint Laws Change

Employment contracts should be reviewed when templates are updated, roles change or the business adopts new employment arrangements. The review should check whether each restraint option remains:

  • clear;
  • severable; and
  • reasonably necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate business interests.

The Commonwealth’s 25 July 2025 Treasury consultation paper considered reforms affecting non-compete clauses and other employee restraints, including whether cascading clauses should be prohibited. The announced reforms were expected to take effect from 2027, but the consultation material did not establish the final law. Employers should check the status of any reform before relying on an existing cascading clause or issuing a revised employment contract.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Makes a Cascading Restraint Effective & Can It Save an Unreasonable Clause?

Clear & Certain Alternatives

A cascading restraint must state each alternative clearly enough for the employer and employee to understand their obligations. Ambiguous terms, such as an undefined “competitor”, can make the restraint clause void for uncertainty because the person bound by it may not know what conduct is prohibited.

The clause should identify the following elements with sufficient precision:

  • The restricted conduct;
  • The relevant businesses or clients;
  • The restraint period; and
  • The geographic area.

Hanna v OAMPS shows that separate alternatives can be understood where the drafting makes their independent operation clear.

Separate & Severable Restraints

Each alternative should be drafted as a separate and independent promise, rather than as one restraint containing conflicting obligations. A cascading clause should also include a severability provision so an unenforceable restraint can be removed without affecting the remaining contract terms.

This structure supports the court’s ability to strike out an unreasonable alternative while leaving a narrower restraint clause to be considered. The drafting shouldn’t require the court to create a new restraint or rewrite the employment agreement.

Reasonable Restraint Periods & Areas Connected to Legitimate Interests

A restraint is enforceable only where it protects a legitimate protectable interest and goes no further than reasonably necessary to protect that interest. In addition, the restraint period, geographic area and restricted activities must be reasonable in the circumstances of the employment relationship. A broad Australia-wide restraint may not be necessary for an employee whose client relationships and confidential information are limited to a particular region.

Cascading Clauses Are Not an Automatic Safety Net

A cascading clause doesn’t guarantee that the restraint clause is enforceable. Its purpose is to provide separate restraint options if a broader period, area or activity restriction is found to go beyond what is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest.

The underlying restraint must still be reasonable when assessed against the employee’s role, the employer’s interest and the scope of the restriction. A cascade cannot turn a clause designed simply to prevent a former employee from working for a competitor into a valid restraint.

What Happens if the Narrowest Restraint Is Still Unreasonable?

If the narrowest restraint period, geographic area or restricted activity still goes beyond what is reasonably necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate interest, the court won’t enforce the restraint. The entire restraint clause may fail because no reasonable option remains within the cascade.

A shorter period or smaller area isn’t automatically reasonable. The restriction must still be connected to the interest being protected, such as protecting client connections during a renewal period or preventing misuse of confidential information.

Uncertainty & Contradictory Drafting

Too many levels or overlapping combinations can make a cascading clause difficult to understand and void for uncertainty. In Austra Tanks Pty Ltd v Running (1983) 40 ATPR 340 (‘Austra Tanks‘), 82,152 possible restraint combinations were held unenforceable due to uncertainty. By contrast, Bulk Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Excell [2014] TASSC 58 (‘Bulk Frozen Foods‘) considered 8,019 combinations permissible.

The number of options isn’t the only issue. Overlapping periods, areas or activities must form a coherent structure, and each restraint must be capable of operating independently without requiring the court to redraft the clause.

Severing Unreasonable Alternatives & Enforcing Narrower Options

Courts in Australian jurisdictions outside New South Wales generally rely on traditional severance rules when dealing with cascading restraints. Under the “blue pencil” approach, a court may strike out an unreasonable word or alternative if the remaining restraint still makes grammatical and commercial sense.

The court can then enforce a narrower promise that is separate and reasonable; however, it can’t create a new restraint or restructure the employment contract.

Each alternative should therefore be drafted so that:

  • each alternative is an independent provision; and
  • the wording is clear enough to allow an unreasonable restraint to be removed without affecting the remaining restraint options.

The Limits of the Court’s Role

A court generally can’t rewrite a cascading clause to make an unreasonable restraint reasonable. The decision in Just Group Limited v Nicole Peck [2016] VSCA 334 (‘Just Group‘) illustrates this limit: removing individual businesses from a list would have required the court to rewrite the provision rather than sever specific wording.

The court’s role is limited to enforcing a valid restraint or removing an invalid part where the remaining promise can operate independently. A clause that requires substantial redrafting may fail, even if a narrower restriction could have protected the employer’s legitimate interest.

Cascading Clauses & the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW)

New South Wales has a different statutory framework. Section 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) (‘Restraints of Trade Act‘) provides that a restraint of trade is valid to the extent that it isn’t against public policy, whether or not it consists of severable terms.

Section 4(3) of the Restraints of Trade Act also allows the Supreme Court, on application, to order that a restraint is wholly invalid or valid only to a specified extent where the person who created it manifestly failed to attempt to make it reasonable. This power may allow a restraint to be “read down” rather than only severed.

Why NSW Employers Should Not Rely on Cascading Drafting Alone

The statutory power in the Restraints of Trade Act doesn’t remove the need for careful drafting. The operation of Section 4(1) has produced differing judicial explanations, including uncertainty about how far a court may modify a restraint and when that power should be exercised.

A NSW employer should still identify the legitimate interest being protected and draft a restraint that is targeted, clear and reasonably necessary. A cascading clause may offer separate restraint options, but it shouldn’t be used as a substitute for a reasonable restraint clause in the employment contract.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

What Does Hanna v OAMPS Show About Cascading Restraints?

The Cascading Restraint in the Employment Agreement

Mr. Hanna worked as an insurance broker for OAMPS for 20 years before resigning to join another insurance broking firm. His employment agreement contained a restraint deed with nine separate restraint options, ranging from 15 months across Australia to 12 months across metropolitan Sydney.

OAMPS sought to prevent Mr Hanna from providing services to specified clients. The court granted an injunction restraining him from dealing with 17 clients for 12 months.

Why the Clause Was Not Void for Uncertainty

In Hanna v OAMPS, the NSW Court of Appeal held that the restraint deed was not one covenant containing conflicting obligations. The agreement stated that each restraint was a separate, independent and severable provision.

The court found that each restraint could be understood and complied with without breaching another. It also held that the clause didn’t need to include a mechanism or hierarchy identifying which restraint would operate first.

What Employers Can Learn From the Decision

The decision shows that a cascading restraint can be enforceable when its alternatives are clearly drafted as separate provisions, but the clause must still protect a legitimate business interest and remain reasonable in the circumstances.

The 12-month restraint was reasonable on the evidence because it gave OAMPS time to renew the relevant clients’ insurance policies. That outcome was tied to the client relationships, Mr Hanna’s role and the evidence about the renewal period.

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Conclusion

A cascading restraint clause can give an employer separate options for restraint periods, geographic areas and restricted activities, but each option must be clear, severable and reasonably necessary to protect legitimate business interests. Hanna v OAMPS illustrates how carefully drafted alternatives may be upheld, while proposed Commonwealth reforms expected from 2027 may change the position.

For employers reviewing an employment contract or preparing a draft restraint clause, the employment contract lawyers in Sydney at Connected Legal + Commercial can assess the structure, scope and possible reform risks. Contact Connected Legal to request a consultation and obtain legal advice tailored to your business and employment relationship.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

JUMP TO...

JUMP TO...

Table of Contents

GET IN TOUCH

Talk it through with a senior lawyer.

Tell us what’s happening in your business. We’ll discuss your situation and outline next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Client reviews

What our clients say

Ready to talk it through?

A senior lawyer will contact you to discuss your situation and outline the next steps, with no obligation to proceed.

Insights

Plain-English notes & legal insights for business owners

Contact

Request a consultation

An obligation-free 15-minute conversation about your matter. We’ll explain where you stand and what your next steps could be.

Phone

Office

Level 5, The Brewery, 5 Central Park Avenue, Chippendale.
Working with clients across Greater Sydney and NSW.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

Tell us about your situation

Your enquiry is confidential. We won’t add you to mailing lists or share your details.

FIXED-FEE REVIEW
Privacy Policy Truth Check

Before 10 December 2026

Is your privacy policy telling the truth?

New privacy policy rules for automated decision-making start on 10 December 2026. Our fixed-fee Truth Check reviews your policy against how your business actually operates, for $1,290 + GST.

Engagements confirmed by 10 December 2026 include the automated decision-making check.