Introduction
A non-dealing clause can restrict a former employee from doing business with specified clients after employment ends, including where the client makes the first approach. Because it goes further than a non-solicitation clause, employers need to be able to justify why that broader restriction is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest.
For SME employers, the practical question is whether the employee’s client influence creates a risk that a narrower non-solicitation or confidentiality clause cannot adequately address. The employee’s role, client relationships, clients covered and restraint period should all reflect the commercial risk the business is trying to protect.
Interactive Tool: Check If Your Non-Dealing Clause Is Enforceable
Non-Dealing Clause Enforceability Checker
Quickly assess if your non-dealing clause is likely to be enforceable for your SME employment contract.
What is the main reason for including the non-dealing clause?
Which clients does the clause cover?
How long does the restriction last?
✅ Clause Likely Enforceable
Speak to a Lawyer about Employment Contract Drafting⚠️ Clause May Be Unenforceable
Get Legal Advice on Restraint Clauses❌ Clause Unlikely to Be Enforceable
Speak to a Lawyer about Restraint Clause RisksWhat Is a Non-Dealing Clause for SME Employers?
How a Non-Dealing Restriction Works
A non-dealing clause restricts a former employee from providing services to or doing business with specified clients after employment ends. Unlike a non-solicitation clause, it may apply even where the client makes the first approach.
Because it restricts the transaction itself rather than only active solicitation, a non-dealing clause can impose a broader post-employment restriction and requires careful justification.
Which Clients or Customers Can Be Covered?
A non-dealing clause should usually focus on clients the employee actually dealt with or relationships they developed through the business. A definition covering every client in the company’s database may be difficult to justify where the employee had no meaningful connection with those clients.
The contract may identify restricted clients by reference to a defined period, such as clients the employee dealt with during the 12 months before employment ended. The relevant client group should reflect the employee’s actual role and relationships rather than automatically cover all past, current or prospective customers.
How Is a Non-Dealing Clause Different From a Non-Solicitation Clause?
Active Solicitation vs Client-Initiated Contact
A non-solicitation clause generally restricts a former employee from actively approaching, persuading or encouraging a client to move their business. It targets conduct such as contacting a client with a competing offer or asking them to move their work to the former employee.
A non-dealing clause goes further because it can restrict the former employee from accepting work from a protected client even where the client initiates contact. The distinction matters where clients have strong personal relationships with the departing employee and may follow them without being approached.
Why Non-Dealing Creates a Broader Restriction
A non-dealing clause can prevent the former employee from accepting work from a protected client even where the employee did not initiate contact. This can affect both the employee’s ability to accept future work and the client’s ability to choose that person as a service provider.
That broader effect can make the restriction harder to justify. The employer should be able to explain why preventing client-initiated dealings is reasonably necessary to protect the particular client relationships at risk.
When Might a Non-Dealing Clause Be Appropriate?
Employees With Significant Client Relationships
A non-dealing clause may be appropriate where an employee has developed strong personal influence over important clients and there is a genuine risk that those clients could follow the employee after departure.
This may arise with senior account managers, advisers, consultants or sales employees who act as the main point of contact for valuable customers. The restriction should still be limited to the relationships the employee actually developed.
Giving the Business Time to Transition Client Relationships
A limited non-dealing period may give the business time to introduce a replacement, stabilise important accounts and rebuild direct relationships with clients after the employee leaves.
The period and clients covered should reflect that transition risk rather than simply preventing the employee from competing. A back-office employee with little client influence is unlikely to present the same commercial risk as someone who personally manages key accounts.
When Might a Non-Solicitation Clause Be Enough?
When the Main Risk Is Active Client Poaching
A non-solicitation clause may be enough where the main concern is a former employee actively approaching clients to move their business. It is narrower than a non-dealing clause because it does not generally prevent the former employee from accepting genuinely unsolicited work.
This may provide appropriate protection where the employee had client contact but there is little risk that clients would independently follow them after departure. The restriction can focus on the conduct creating the actual risk without imposing a broader prohibition on future dealings.
Choosing the Narrowest Restriction That Protects the Business
Employers should consider whether a narrower non-solicitation clause can adequately address the risk before using a non-dealing restriction. If the main concern is active client poaching, preventing solicitation may be enough.
A non-dealing clause may be more appropriate where the employee has unusually strong client influence and the business faces a genuine risk even from client-initiated contact. Restraint of trade lawyers in Sydney can help assess which restriction fits the employee’s role and client relationships.
Are Non-Dealing Clauses Enforceable for Australian Businesses?
Identifying the Business Interest Being Protected
A non-dealing clause is more likely to be enforceable where it protects an identifiable business interest, particularly established client relationships developed through the employee’s role. Preventing ordinary competition is not enough. The employer should be able to explain why dealings between the former employee and particular clients would threaten an interest the business is entitled to protect.
The restricted client group should also reflect the employee’s actual relationships. A clause covering every customer or prospective customer may be difficult to justify where the employee had no meaningful involvement with them.
Justifying the Broader Restriction on Post-Employment Dealings
Because a non-dealing clause can restrict client-initiated work as well as active solicitation, its scope requires careful justification. Courts may consider the employee’s role, the clients covered, the activities restricted and the restraint period. A clause may be difficult to enforce where it operates as a broad restriction unrelated to the employee’s actual client influence.
The duration should reflect how long the business reasonably needs to transition and protect the relevant client relationships. There is no standard three, six or twelve-month period that is automatically reasonable; the appropriate period depends on the employee’s influence, the client relationships and the commercial circumstances.
What Happens if a Former Employee Deals With a Restricted Client?
Determining Whether the Clause Has Been Breached
Start with the wording of the clause. The employer should check whether the customer is within the defined client group, whether the restraint period remains active and whether the former employee has actually provided services to or dealt with that client.
Client-initiated contact may still be caught by a non-dealing clause, but the employer should also assess whether the clause itself is sufficiently clear and appropriately connected to that employee’s client relationships before taking enforcement action.
Evidence of the Client Relationship & Subsequent Dealings
Evidence should show both the former employee’s relationship with the client and the dealings said to breach the clause. Relevant records may include emails, messages, proposals, CRM records, system access logs and communications showing that services were provided or business was transferred.
Employers should preserve relevant records before sending a letter of demand or considering an injunction. Evidence about who initiated contact may be particularly important where the employment contract also contains a narrower non-solicitation clause.
How Should HR Professionals Decide Whether to Use a Non-Dealing Clause?
Assess the Employee’s Influence Over Clients
HR should assess the employee’s actual client influence before inserting a non-dealing clause. Consider which clients they manage, how regularly they interact with them and whether clients rely on the employee personally rather than primarily on the organisation.
The clause is more likely to have a genuine commercial purpose where those relationships create a realistic risk of clients following the employee. Job title or seniority alone shouldn’t determine whether the restriction is used.
Compare Non-Dealing With Less Restrictive Protections
Before using a non-dealing clause, compare it with narrower protections. A non-solicitation clause may adequately address active client poaching, while confidentiality obligations may better deal with the misuse or disclosure of commercially sensitive information.
The aim should be to choose the restriction that matches the actual business risk rather than automatically inserting the strongest available clause into every employment contract.
Conclusion
A non-dealing clause can provide stronger protection than a non-solicitation clause because it may restrict dealings with protected clients even where the client makes the first approach. That broader restriction also means employers should use it selectively and connect it closely to the employee’s actual client influence, the relationships requiring protection and a reasonably necessary restraint period.
For many employees, a narrower non-solicitation or confidentiality clause may provide sufficient protection. Employers should assess the business risk before choosing the restriction and review the wording against the employee’s actual role. Connected Legal + Commercial’s restraint of trade lawyers in Sydney can help review and draft post-employment restraints that reflect your client relationships and commercial risks.
Disclaimer: This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should seek advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on it.